From c5fa346898e89f322ae41f2a1623a084e57ff32c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Thomas Pietrzak Date: Fri, 12 Apr 2019 18:59:13 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] Outline --- figures/delegationevolution.pdf | Bin 0 -> 12472 bytes figures/delegationevolution.svg | 188 +++++++++++++++++++ figures/instrumentedinteraction.pdf | Bin 0 -> 13544 bytes figures/instrumentedinteraction.svg | 278 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ figures/logo_cristal.pdf | Bin 0 -> 3417 bytes figures/logo_inria.pdf | Bin 0 -> 30478 bytes figures/logo_univ_lille.pdf | Bin 0 -> 5248 bytes figures/partner.pdf | Bin 0 -> 12685 bytes figures/partner.svg | 262 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++ hdrmain.tex | 14 +- tex/conclusion.tex | 2 + tex/controlautomation.tex | 17 ++ tex/directmanipulation.tex | 15 ++ tex/gestural.tex | 17 -- tex/haptics.tex | 19 -- tex/introduction.tex | 194 +++++++++++++++---- tex/perceptionaction.tex | 18 ++ tex/physical.tex | 17 -- 18 files changed, 941 insertions(+), 100 deletions(-) create mode 100644 figures/delegationevolution.pdf create mode 100644 figures/delegationevolution.svg create mode 100644 figures/instrumentedinteraction.pdf create mode 100644 figures/instrumentedinteraction.svg create mode 100644 figures/logo_cristal.pdf create mode 100644 figures/logo_inria.pdf create mode 100644 figures/logo_univ_lille.pdf create mode 100644 figures/partner.pdf create mode 100644 figures/partner.svg create mode 100644 tex/controlautomation.tex create mode 100644 tex/directmanipulation.tex delete mode 100644 tex/gestural.tex delete mode 100644 tex/haptics.tex create mode 100644 tex/perceptionaction.tex delete mode 100644 tex/physical.tex diff --git a/figures/delegationevolution.pdf b/figures/delegationevolution.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c4c97d821768978651d42a9ae35445f9be6b32dd GIT binary patch literal 12472 zcmbW8bySqy-uDHiTO=fhmSza)?gr^*=%HgMDd}$ME@cW`R@!;n z@}PZNC8bs%m5_R|tVDuI1*S*z!&JMz)Vp1Aw5L_VTx+d2cQLzoizEEteT&M;<~Ohv z#-eRy{6VnUxuoOA^ce{vlD8^)dnbJ3Qqd`?PPoWWT<~?VQLqt1B^hcc2(Dj?a<66h zWqZ%}Oov-UVvZcV_*OLq^>%p_1(y7xNaw-+JtXwxIOW6zt}^Z!?akP1zBZ@+ob%6R z?lww}qX0>b1KD&|T@g`OQ9tfG&m@-fjF!j(1<=P!HA#0HdSvAD(b5Ng*>>6jUAEaD@`h`CIA4Gu!xB%ok*<)nmvX!H zBiW3GpS;GrBu75@;Hu$6NSvGumUYR8{fTI^FJJP`-(OQpl4}t+MpbS%iF9T^{=5jT z#Ji!97^D3Br4solHW;>jtiGjCe9XxsCI&nH%j)vngCeXB?P)V}<>^A$;Y)6L3-5HL z&FI{New3HolwQQT-~7KCDg_EJhf5*Y-k!Ab79PHg9rFuuK;mmqM|Y09{im=CvZ<}fpNRwg_LOo@dG>UNW*P?v*VFT-7VF;$ z`8x&0-5`=G5NP@V`1qa#=*0|Tfi?ilqQU?mfY}%X{e&hZ^uZsW%o29CkbmoK#>m3R z0^s;7siB>quRj-i`}bl1W>t54QvkCP$lUbz!b%`VQ|LUvzs51ko0@<@B6e;79jL?t zU}a}#VrS*zddm&~vavC7vT(DpZ~*jvj}?XP06N$S@KjxYl#-;QowNPF?dp%!eye|( zr2^f9Bgodt{%K`n_rGLm0L0Px_nw|?7lrl`Gj#zQo4%72dFt|~(eF&1?3^8qO`QNw z4t)1-HgZDS|EO@Tzqj?jRru2~e;frs01#>-%YW4T_xJ9es?+CJO_y!%HRG*XtRAd( ztg<51_)@TBm_sO(A0#e5yp{vNkhd@h2Zj+8BZ|E$Rx7FVn`zde4u`;=$rfAap&ZOE zSgI+3`|7bQ8Ovl@e>fe=VS3wiba;FFJS?X<9X4HNwq!W{YT9ajf%ptR`}qr{#8R-{ zWlJ|HAKZ!{k`Nw4lWpFK{R*cK>|hCO3_-bmgZ1cM8aBo=u?xfNRMQep122jDQ!=8} z*ZV5%t!2(Tyx{_=NSFh3_$@^A`=-sVm3-(Uu^U!zZBswV&{Qr3Y%EM$CDp>V3ZjkN zR`S`%?|pJkohF#^CKwrRMzh(=wUZZwRVsbX@_?sQuZh;)sLd!eh+8cVBm;EMhD|)y z75i2QVcpK}v-5}4B8>{?*T$G4g!Iu(xw9uclyZjO<;_|r;-567vZUm@zsHv4;A4!H z92$X)oHL%FgQD-kHmN=v2+$Kcr@ly0G#?s?l)kR`)RFpV`8AySD}(lnJmCr~@%Z`N z_*!l3HJ+jTzKu2Z;%SrIQ=zY^>2qRmzSA3(Ji=J=3i}1)Qx*{SI6%QRj~WKg6b&8K zM-oa2KyT54JaR2Kkh`YWcnwK;j^ZUyJj62HbaytB1<6CMw|BT&%|lMsZpOvp^M&o6 zPRDWY#(3JS2iDQn>lg%2eRsoWeA8;}zPl=FC(j=0t(Zaw>^?@@cJ%f*8P#a0FVN99 zj7UanN0EFlA6n0ojJ?Tsu=QfKyYTDR|4O%Ai!fylGx>-gtmtR0`GaUnG5KR`CFV;a zGBR}l7*6{_cHwGy%KwMYmCZ@gZQ(k?Fgrp=x(GVP^d#K+a{Jz4W5!TeC*#gkw=@u* zgtZ34bH`gP>nBrTSdW^me8G6Jsf)S$k}x?>@Q4@@Q{D@B9U&Hx6#89<5>w+5ui^+1 zXS|bdwpE6yGLKpusiPsG5wo_`=6PS=j5_g}Y8h?#RJ!!asnauOsf@~9fH`+uu`f{# zkY{661nT*Ac=z)5Ja0Xv4Hjr_&QFZ+~cVUj;%+svR zceL32XUm-2`{BCC>ZWtHRu%J{>@m|hJUe|-(ik9j@X@FWhZ}M+LUBn69ev6NiRjc; zt@F_8K5GsY>5_N|K?YzbcL>8QV>EgoxHmkkUWBcyJqP%XOAwbnB(f@DKHWB{q!hBR z8H6&eg@iyW7r~Ux!Eo!`yh5m^()=0n|0Vh%0gD4kf~lIrgQF0_)f{{Fdb4vT_B3*<8Kg z<|avcKlQJ_rl{-g7k+9>r^)yX&j$@|wW-rf3hbHgPnnHb;DSoU)<^WI`5C8>DSm!Z zH(KgF0eh#{A?(O}%dOJWFz8h4pB-1s>BdkWDio+NY8CsY4z8$8NEoWfcFDVu_@1t8 zY`qFJtw+|;QkdH`S<0FOQawze5JYT9p7ahK}m`hS$YW*4~KxjOGqTQGzmBN$`JI^KM)O_nwrhN3MAY| z=C2fqN_aqDVffBcfcX=QyI1SA?kOkEF${Gn%*TlvGfly!&&t!|(_f~UXBcL}^SNOn zddV~*80iCv3IkwY1jmD~l20_b42r!VTj3oP<%AEA+t3`}_Fo4L&X?AU%ksqeD`R^> z0{EUk6@O5>_uk!DRXm>b&FXKwZzrxu6wF4|TbG#5!JXf;MIz-LL*62a8~j#2 zY{B${A^vb^fS-mR99^`Xj$1fFGGP(A&Pwv}Fysm|3*8--Q9AlSs{i69| z(HCAHw|V}dunu*c6nT2XvBl9Eq~jhD$~I7cA8Yl)%H1u|dYe(3qwL-R=x*OL9gc1X89}vMo%SC0sb&h&U+cbjGe)ntyvXUc;sBinI{ZLm-$k0N6`LJ|LdK$ zlR}Pd#>*LxyD)vsZg&`31P(2c&q2qV>_pLV{9nD437lKJ61PbRt3o3R-(v9UzV%*Y z8Cyt?sCnzM^gW{G?Qo;jPnu3@;KM>P7k;=+k3a~cc&b`FO*4YxE7CC^Z!SSn^pULM zw{O$4P)6(wdq4+D67qL<$UP^so`!;i<8ZYML{tO5`@UX6^Ra26-q?HbBWgmMlIojb zhHGIf!*t!VOZ~7@GBmS@&u2rvXkAF;(pG<_>HSr96*11tQbkz&2_rL(x#;y3d^9J< zSdmr9ea{VA5r$e3mfDmlMB3WcJI_?D$HU~tOwNQ0JQz$Wf1*>18$0~z9ZL1bhEM4Vz zt=UH9@WVr3oUjO=!QWEVp@qK`nn!|TkWXp5U+dn&1jlPa9FmKp2G26q! zHHH5I*4X!RC*KVF3}3%v$Ec!dszKD8Z0T3_A zsv&1qH4l4R)Nk2hSs1=Ax&JMbJRV(BTHxC?T4|`0teRY&9GiSMgUW)~SMiK*Dn{bV z6TA8y)o_RACd+_Rc`uS*sqfdv72P*fM)wdrN!&jeZ!6-1#dK`67-L!BQ(QFG5P&rEqCKT}hW?)FvDpA!?QB!<-^+FI?;x37vz8kA~Ix_DKBjf$M`bi8~86&YX}?(4>2ubES@v-zQ0D3 zEs2y}S03!{GB@c^pB1lnsf_x>G?AIYLm(=YN9fFI`PLez1>hRffB&K(AltBGK~FB7-5wXJ1E5#Q2D zMgX@GMfh)Q+}$+Rg_u%Gn*A{cyCzDtrb@HSt+Ca?GrNls&FQK)sx#_^il3eE6A2B$ zzV|kxNn=g|4z*sbu8{10f$tjF$u@Q;V@S0Nvsc>B)AHrHx3;;XBNPIs_g%&v>l$a8 zUTAbSOD@x>XyM+&_~W8a7JkUTzS zku7f)?^OcLXzxCX(PtV0dJMgsm<|NjMMW!oS6UQ zaO!I79{0udu`=mJsE}N~{q}thvx(_r*T#D0A~mxQ12(VGyDsO8yypbvl?461VGbL7 z%%t%{l96NU*UFhC$`LGOso7=~n*kE(p+j1cnBPjLAQqDZSQ*66aT+oDB-gx^6y}pp z+JtUa87xQL%`G&;o1Q1!DvsgI8cmooe_PEw<=Q(z* zf|;z*Sj?`u%ARLf^vd`akbddv&HO?7-snQ6QxEl)>@?RtlL=q{s$RMpny2yTGLk%A zP)(z^YVxL&mJJ9Vks~mT>=VGWUg^bO-&XB?&8WLMGB`j6eRXuKQ8mR3uDABta;(SY`%Yek$m~N z`}wkHpk&(svQNUPeopy}_z8ZCwRMBbEoW9}fBq!Rv^y$FvwxA8Cw#7%7Kf#IE&Pi{Nld6K`r@&t_KMTYBsDek&D^cm0XQ*o%3DV#u0 zK%J@>fUS|WNKcOLN5j_sWae@$nc@%@NlTj6bgTTlNox{UE`R=tVqnKH*w`<>E<4vO zJpd>&J=vaci=k+f_10{fcSK6-dsG_d7B&AY(T}E|pS7x&GkmyK^gSUqDm$q-Bc!1l z%dB?8Q;TNS8LPF)Ua>{1sj*4aGafTP^egK1y@x*47}&Hxh} z(x=tX(s?APi<7NN*ZHP)BG40`s&SgI*VFvL?SA8CVesy*{*Lj6_q;)Z#EDPuuGMg+ z#f#*!=w_{9i9j$z^0TfCY9_T_eEZOZi8U)nipH+`t_FcRfkvu&s)unK+>D=QK7iH8 z+QgR(q)VWq-3V+2PGU7J9%b*8ci)B`zCJHnm7c;tAz|DPZNqoML6?la?vZlC4@IR& z4?3px!AHWNhy_t5!696<4#PG36%7GyK59l;v{KFn7ix`O;<8;Jv`sIkEQ>GSFB|I* z?V`P(eXr=&m+jh+^xh|Ia!7b|W!Z1nWSvzRDPhQg{X~rVqdNw_f`)s4c;(zMQd2&y zt25Im+PX#G7vU|1S<)cl62T&LY9pY1C@|zwsJDcNZ=;~p1Bo|BUy<5$>)W1@_L`ce zVnz3R_iLnc$LOwbiCi5*+V1jkIJ#)OSn{_hd&<3E7zl$XN)gC?_&RxTuCG+d&J46= zZe_vFU`bj=(@ez|d@1+|^ciuhtQiAX_0NKe^y?9+j5bK?OFiAy17o%3y$X)(N4u$O z9dE&-f-nJr-LG2nYJSO|-t1_xv3>v;*MlTxI(vWa9dF)HM-g{kC19yxly1QXeIF@Y z7tS;-m75tf{)`x7`-pn$JYg-;6C0`ZRYYve#A2RZniv9shX0-hNH5 z-+Vl`xIWogjAm1p6vY2^a-@DNxw(l2Kg*?ubv*qOH_ob1c@HLS$^2xk;bFpfWyj!B zc>5sDcK93sFDxVvL+s<2>aX5#mG09Xjo`)ehTQ_3b}Np(vx9ye_6Ga{*d+a03 z%8*}fX%=|A7_Xe-+1KR$sPSmVHF#q_K<%Al9Di)Zsy|w3o9*FW*FzG;r>Ul8^z){3 z+P9_W%Xfz+C1mYHZHwdp8D&-Dxg^wxVHtYrNmOs-t7S8|p zVMv-Hs$F^CZ{6~Ik$$}4@iusc=r9gp(0`rG^V0N3(veq6>s`miog%59$JJ#tZQ9-g zV<2}LVRchxp+w9x3iT+R&M@8Fd6$F7J&{Kr@1s%=EYH+|u8{{9gqR2XRrZl!^?bz| zm&7SSatAt;XNsLQCUATxk}K|xxE=?=0^5N}U1)Vj0BhgFZkLZeu%+`zPDj&*_pYIw z-%+TJScca@ZqLCL0ck6Mpl_LHG(|&;0gwIqi%R9!O3!Ny8JC31r3_Hy?L}JQ=vI&$ z;b&r_AjUUiXL>u5tCABmt?49Up|^%e?RNQs(|2$0nId{gE<5k-{gw)R&{fk5p40j~ zBV2*W(W2Zj-C=fsBWom?1$0B){LiMiqL$%Fu`%Y!<@%MqlNCNildC;T1#$B|Lm0wm zO$cI_-`UyW>qrEs8+5x9Xb|HKvasJ%;xJ}+ z1iw%<8qvODzTzgL0iCcls~b;#v{W5!n6&f5mgwQrJ@`3yim`rpM(t^btN*evpC*Ue z&i|0bwkP}u<~a5xYy6i&if!$im`a#&Dc}V$nk)$JRl>k8&BBH5u38BFto+AcPF+oUyNtOZ zF4i<%@x*vW6W(j|rmR+9{b8`SDB(8UdkIaZQao=ug>KjKIi}^@CV8h8$onFP?d=KX z;D<~m`5*8#%B1ycyN6v;4S474_^pwLNLMiyA+efAYEmIzC^%O;=a8OTDI#rEfASLI^vKf(zbNFUOYV_XH^iBZSV$FPMD%2bma>@^IPSupza&OR7B z;y0ZUI>OIde}ZW@Yn|Gm*gLf%-vh~w-n@P-!RD(3_4)a3Q zLg<3l!u*2Sf$agzL0U8Jw=ujG?yI3d^UU;D^~lcMPWCj6*llNcXLv>9;f9}CGIBpn z(hQ=%r`RdL8l?uqW(b*eY5{{cb6!kW>5WT|~UZAp(t{d7imI7wk70aChJ0|Dr>}Zr4B@}3Qzp;x*xnX)U zl+ti^JJq72-D))J6%DWrs#xF=NYP#g$H2oJcIX#j3i#<5;@mT$u5d5IT*elxu{L54 z58__olk}(nMVum4DK}y?wvnsid8C+?j-{9Ms6sJ?e+KAC*BpI-1hu2hb_2gYJ46{@ z*^T~6iZaz#lge$vo%w-q^{r;sGIAP6w-WUe~Aq2Is<5vk5ecmu_@1Dzdu|@`FPYY-5)#Y$k z0`Bpbvh?9+^AG)EEimc}8&*OTI}bsee8Tl;-=FOrDR>i(U*M$Do+X>fyr(?Kx0`A@ zTMpj{Uy6E(afkJT)EJbzi3tho@NL2mJdk-LsB6Jw+`q5HX9`wn98q)#0*eTKL>tZ4 z+oA2|Svo{Y&hX|Vri9nb)Q^n10A0nZKQCM08s?Jr4!muHS=dfLlgP2LfI9(kItq*1 z>V;pJ7xK94i$-emA5Rt|{iGjIi=btuC+06+kBjX)&czCZtFoX>Cw=GV-UQPzzSp&~ zv{SigQqpJ5N^o}9(=3GaYBsR2_RWx{?7N7-LV3cW;Z^lgi?-}ss?UbgAH%_MGAJ}E zOrKO^Pj(;u-;F92Z_$R9stQjJ8Wk{=QvN7Hqo=JlbfH*t{T75R(v!L0s0wu(T5HM+aD(?)38;f<8eU7_iY9f16k%26^R||UH`2U}QgZ!% z#S|vY%|y3@GCM=nwyIt4mycOyrI(t{(Na}DLyAl#flD*APPN)6ji@N2{WJXq^(i=R zay>s$F|X9H#dk5GeC=UOkM=cgL$ADSkE~7_LA;2S-zX^jXKS7GWrKoyJMG%a#ZcrT zv-LSjhI1wkGQEq7tw!9f8K?dnff1P8*Vxd2AY*cp8?JCUP_8tqWW^eylM9rtU;T)@ zh_t9?=3}$UqdryrPI|W|zI%jMqdwchGebJLhWp#W>1VH<_>~eB9zuei9Fsc1bc-@H z2zQRt*d|Fuu^Y4PYpo@!Mb?OeYR#IEAy2YNm-a~G^mNd<)0k6YB~Bo-XrL6G>?>Vq zWBg0@C@Pzu*-k@Tlsz=Ul^Tw;GA82h1e*#}NXB=y9`mW`f)mC%U@V2)R>tvWYt5|k zi|#lL-%Q1y76%>lxUrHb;^F{tzA8whtP#+hoFvEg%@$a2wJNByh+cFttlL-_c_LK{ zzA}Ps=P&3sVxZ(T<1`yaX1H+m*M6x;2}ZHnA+;S!8PMhl(iwBLL&~GRJQ1Rx`5d0{ zsAZazXM24`>2S|HYLjwt)3kask3x{pJeJ5{w@1iCXSy(uVK-tVJ+Lm(rC5W1j?#*g zP`$$kq-Rf!GkWFoQe(G(whX;4ZWhy2=ACUyqBM4p(zf7!z%kigUyWU}X;KOiX-6a9 zYVL{n2%9r5+-Vagxksv~kQ4jhe~4 ziNuGSq|d{+%;ab0$1eorcqMTag+*uQxv5I!cC2@-KzzRBh~%B;)c$Z(=SuC#5?9afXQ4tML9>fp^ngg%!>xcg+p%{s(IsxxVpLDW#v zt~V!6bH2{!$v<*aFfhoxxxJ9I^@oF&$ z0=hGkY25BASzr~&l|W*ye4KMMuMnHQWBXakAYRTn$&_(Wz+GS!1Qa5FvckHcAQHv| z#l{TeI?35dYzxgr+rL=l@(b`7{8@(FtsT&YNTU@VL;s>VAzN1k;8s?;eu`eFOMO>m4ZqL?@6;RVEj}|#>6UM{U)^J&I(wsu zBYG`qZgK{s8o>z&QgQHp-R;2u9A`nDt?76mf|epg1gFVU0xh{ z+i5Xk*^P0W4x609!pVUXewFCLBKwTJ%YNtq{D`-hafn5x$-{`qUO21H0S$(){K8mJ zge9Y0f3nlQFXeqptNF8AXme{tBC12!VDozKj4HE3!eITHK6wlDKE5%?7;1d<%G$I=oF4?|B%r;i)k2ZFT0b%s65(_)OT0()< zYvZF3^lu5m9B*IaD1oG{?+QXd)f)4Jd6xUjw^f62a~ZB={c&?;EttmA`#L&U#?sd3 z&LLHl^$;o}hEPV$0DM^^HbTrEN^#N~>3o1D&~Q;0S2%$f0oK$HxFrZXBa=EEgt*G{Mw+o-i*KthPVBLksFKxAmmLp zo>HWKr?7q}Olh(@1%t@8B$t1TL`)11DPDV8p}L$bW--)zOA*lgSsUT@7XsP1gx+3v z%T$MF4#}LsdCmuiV4{6)aukXhnF{z0V>C*^b~@=^3#-e-KI4)$mPo$&+=uh==b_oe z?DkFugmXO?aA9)#{ky?Byvn-A_bSn@R3b;x_0S^c{Fg?QVb@$1TN^;kiKO_1}45hQaD|o&tU5c=@VcR>MIV*M_KT0+Gcl4(gV!Zf)x{uoaE^ZPu zx~dsw=%Tcm@8#>zWp1#MuT!<^`)fs>ffutC$imS`*Gag*iiWaSm9OpZWQ5{3W#78c zxt6^UWlVyoj(`ha!m4Vlnf1I&xiP>Ep0T?x3h_v~$KA8j9f!7BmvLsf#OB-Bx2Wkv z%kVlf8>O_8bE^!V7KIrt2z7>V;gmFwvZQmiQ?=mKz&zT)$18EhPzD@sCY8j=F9`~v zQAQSN5XAFZ?_ZSfvi1#N&%+beo0?W%0kda6At{ned+>kbl#_`HpDnE2;T{Te^Lod- zSKQAe@=MOpChnJzT|o{|e6rLsEvrw`ODM!j$i}uTGf_ZYd8jCn=9bXiIROYXufW(XG408GV(Igt6S_u>pPJ; zvs|e><*tf}K;iSiJGdPsx%5Dp{z%AdR(-gBg{bo`uFTH;nrou5*LytIunmacB1*}vY-U?+e0*t~- zfPez)BVk+|!_e3%CGWKy>~#=zOb#%M=o2tYEcMFgrdB>|Kzcl&H;x+Dvp!&N0aH7! z!JuI&eqXcnjh^hw`6Bk2YPTWB#D;n*?A7{(^*H;oNsgQy19r};O{CQYCW~S#i+#&? ziQYN+9l4~p@k&Vkg_-~i-!APLq%dJXFv%y*s zXt7lXajd2o$>UxGk}a+`fkg&=V)$Zh;;I&KGhZA>&ej{CWH#f}r5NxEXx1HT_aDg- z*gd*p)K61Q&n#R-K06=EZ8{&aJlk!l)h@LG>BvNpma`G;vGfnA>iZ@9)G7d^)0jA` zl`2$>zkH~MA{+qjdqQCy+ z?zrD_u>8fsasM|b27ChD{%4h0n`JINk)HD9nTw!`rB}ww)M^ z=HbDG2HQk(U5+v2+T>hiuMqUWx6rid9tl4aI>u#(-=m)M%0O^I(>V08m%z(;rH4R( zmf-RFevgadl~(H^N1x5o1?BC?)e@gb#t)o^eB8(qQk=ZVQ-&xXi{l8 z0(U)7b8YBk7-d;=z4*+iMVDAOdnZk(MI*i>YqITq^jW*ZK8~#$C^hYn^By`kEoR24 zk-4VYN*Wr!A6!x#<=E>**nIBL%k)cIzlJ@O-y% zi06VFZ}#8e`0eCBAZ^{2nIkWc)-&ay7 zKnb1Zx1<6wwNVE^X~HMI@Tnp7SL4YDD2Qmv3V31_|D9cYqBj5A2Y<}qYy|mDY^p-( z$S42&Rz*NgroZ{m|J5I0M<|DNGrPv8E|o&UWj2ghG?{OcPl z>k}LbWmlnhE;cqOcKi1C`$=PaYD2@$%E|e+2E}Hf%5SC>%BI?>*@B-CaKO_^@$XUk z?@WE7Xq|q0Miy-H(ty!)Gub$$YC{|!+E{tNnr60T6V9Gc#MH^v~aqa6Uq1Y~F8 z0=%(+KhJj|I}Dm z-f}|C{fEW^gr@pGH0as<4-E)pXM>i=Kl*WUK?Crg8no#Cxh{}}lLJaz|3^Ql295SV zG$4=z>W=^H2Ly6LBlr)E8+uawLt|y(_&3`ijv#1NJO2J{feQG&>65RXivOLR9W?&` kVxy&P&7g69%7Ncm + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + image/svg+xml + + + + + + + + + Autonomy + Time + + Tool + + Partner + + Trust + Betrayal + + + diff --git a/figures/instrumentedinteraction.pdf b/figures/instrumentedinteraction.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..df1bdd718f30278948bc575bc8b72289d9b3afe1 GIT binary patch literal 13544 zcmbW8WmH?+xAvj9dvO|ym10To7I$}dhu~hkr8vbY?oudDad&qu4#nNwUue%c_b>Ou z9q&%q+3Q(8*PLsFjNhV?6B1znF|s04RqhwxA~OSk02>2yWG*fMla#TwsiPTy;PqTEbJz3Ejt>hMTQG&Rq%~BoxNcZ&Kk? zjxNhvH@&5$p`41eD#~Wk(GwAk-$8YL+W1Zi=72J@pQqeV5yqy??}>=hfyBwte2 za&&k{sEn(WJDhcfYBHRW`D1(d+r4I9V-?AUZMz0m$nr^ElWrm^r@xYQB}=X0c*nu zR&N!J!og+b&APh!&KSg48MiNq>aH%OdjXUVEPLI7B7Y~gNSFC4V z@G>}WDfiCNhG+AW!NpUD$MUC+9=}=}77V5IQdVm?w4Y-PJe^>tWMKqvmdboXTF9vx z5xmO!qf2=*BH7lZ)@_wQ-`1BxU*X$+5GXT5F)Z$D-!DvWpN&F)B~lH`D7lgz>^?ns zHrNw|&Ia`#3y_ke2KQoaJ)?7UnAR<(X_G~=-SNrslH2-R<)kSYkPGcp0d%tQpk4g# zaKYrsNv4eR?l;7RbidMt?c@)6;WkJjcWH=Tk(m zgV~<*pHtv}0_S(A2)j6nDmp%e34n|1S$Mjb^np(a0Fxj;00dw%)PK4^1ow5DX8GuR2)z%omB&Tm`{JUd0eS71lc0hmEW0E#D zg6Ip_xBxVtBp`qd$jQjY!pZ?+27uU@8G#^nAUi8S`*&Tzrx83=b^tu@0)IkY)ZWI) z_FqQzr?=ng-_ufj8iT#QwS(<*&xWpl%i;h>d#B%HdY-%BQz;>1XNaM(f~dfAk-sLb zVC-PyWN&Ef0C+Z_!oSRs{VDw)I}yh}!}{NLqUUb@Y*`=xh?Rwt?cesMefKXPl{(L_ z2Ii-lE)Pt~pF+Uo719hJ0Lj-^%o+gA!qqlTPaOpniOGlk0`Z*RY+YX{qsm;EE?wzZ znGNF_zJn?6b>$ns5{yD6IJ|OeUWqRtKr>_F;PlSEH>H>r|7}XjTX4X9qnGlV&_{5T(Bu_JqZHhy!Ma_CB z-z?RcZO>{B4bQogiMWuFFR6y2oukMO-Z~Nq)N;$Q=VQGsyiVj5NEm}9jw{k)zSrL- z^!1-h=YnjXz?~x!@1|?PtoQcsOtGN!`;N;k!We&Z6&7^ZTKg&}=S50>|B*rfpRNU^ zAO`b9^DY*XlHhm?!Eg7TA8+JRY}wr#Insr9M8pq<57PGKLO)uax?EiLZufxl#HxDq zjl$YzB36Qq84Va|xY&)p_I2Sz5v!DjggNR*8IIQ%eVfLOB7rNM*%H@)*<$d-ELdS#PI(n!iY`8AZjf;} z{%A&f0}O~trI_KB0#$qjj9NJGXMu{(XCg{#5xkGdyn_yNE(4c(g*yePjbjj)>cLNF z74%8pR(d4dZ_9A;tfDYpv61pLh>NXJ_^a1@n15iXTU{4_BMH!Q|~pOe8fd(630|&^R0m-rCe3 z>eQ(cD0ephy1Dw%6T0b)3HDN{)X>u~?K0t3k;gOlzuzd*X}6)F9=j!rhXjXW7uTu%={siAF77pTr+r%? zd}W0GS%2qD<}I$V*X8Qr#f76Nk{F3BN=;IPWLHh;JS*)4&Nx-lOhf*IQRFE?!f5rh zgiVV{L|lyeX-dd*rkO%fVc6m-5|p7wxFr5)jfhLCb7S2nV*9~;3EmRZk@tw*?xLc% zDq4YOMS4rt41JZj>wT4`%j^am`Btr!4Dx%JoqX_RxN4&7n=_;e93(xMidGkQ4f0yz zqO-NSX+&2hopF~9N8UCi77O!(!v{_E+g=T=$GY8iL_fL1dv6-+xg=woZZ3LNy`(Pb z2_6%TP{IKSH|<{8UoM^D+TdnWT}m|I#gb5(e(Fu=qt6&ybrj<4>&V!|GRwiUX$ZoT z#IfMb2EWTATysk5pb(FAmH_3cz9SD(ki9Ee0GrVQ@aqOm{5=*1*|;;R#eJI(>IVGEn9X@GwMx1aS zg&AN@*Qr(5`gU8(KWK$=kOY*kPRaPw40+AK;)iE;xj=D+$}C+nt3ar;zm`Q&<*+Ry zPAmk!ufMQ=4<)5~S*hp^fz65uQn@2LVXQrxfRA+^|K`z2RA<4|+-I^FNWmnoh&8d@e|yfDGHSDVR45|o0Yr< zxBDM!FVFav9)_fe-`BHQ?oiTloIXs#yt;gK+aGTCj;-msE9vocmRK}_dl6Q2FHH|) z|4N2c_*VyRndm_z?>dhx=diXEmTSH_m78I!2H~Rs&ob9)$a_~|L*|)1l@fsdsPzP) zG`!+So`Sby8N-OFyp~PY=e)z9kKZ)jl$=QkofC$9PVIE-V`>bwNA6q7bL-=53_C#j z%9KAqwljGr4`;{ipXQYxec)TKr^G+tx+tEQ@;(J*S`z)CZ9Cc=L!ZNk$yt-W6c0%< zk`EjC^YmUIE#k_I%qSa53K~|GEY}?8J3qV)E{p+woBbAp zdT3H}B@Ly(uUekS?Y0vxn>JK0Kd|@kP9Q}T1h-Cz-=bdyE<#&KsY0{DPhIsgo*#B1 z{%FDFJ(P3LJ!nvtqdqoPV+rby+E@0#33ae!&l$2~MV1`1u3ofQ7~(dVJy`Jh5X~L? zL7KM5f4)rG`Sh2j=R|_CFYT$n30|*>udA#?o%d<>sRpNI6SN;52lfJwsM@GrsCTi* zs)VlGYKT+}laP7tnKT@{>~?)bgx41zqE|r47GgQHh8O58JP}xw6exwQcU(NKnUP9K zF?~Es_kB(c5~o&sl0 z9B&?#D@T^Oq(-<08b8f?`v$wBI_kZ7Y=OTRIo=CgLlC%vZJQV;pU{%_DG#|2H{79M zcA#OV0t2baX#92&ocjRzqii|Sdx7G!{HnkSpDD-dZ9ALSW(dWh8`zv{8#(bMf<0ctZ9e~k(SFDk=4?C1AEXTpUU!H}65;V$_+ztokz-Exc2 z${Fdd&KalnxlrN&%WB>oudet+*6&{v9Q(C#-TTfhfAUO8st0IymoG}(10@x$ySKk4 zyzCPxIG6YiE~D`hNs$JnwQq*38R6p|3v*7LM%!gx=lz2rE#W7}*X?+=I|U(`~}gA_mlXsxlG<1Z425;&s0B_e2->40mW6D2Okjr4dJ zqWPnH`#D?47dJgdHqIq13l=P+>A+5|zxL7c;&vl@C@I%4K68|{ewJc{SVa)(zDe89 z$;8Rd7j7nvz)<2&VeFwsM(;B!4VceP1S{jlwoACUxY($@c`?^U(rznzx5ncilJ1lr znK~fcC~Rbk#b`fL88eDSN^UA*eH7uMMalC+i83?DE3ZcYX;gfQ0?hd`0fe1U6AVt# zA_3i$nZhz&`86SypG^gtiGN%xAO2qSj+l0Tmls7L;l0?>3%DH~@9zrCU2CAvka=GX zfwKK)=&fEZc5|V;ayX+`F_BD&0=mBiYxd1^f4_gXtga?C z5IlxxIO3JR8V{`vK_mN&cvFEJ=R)K!4I|2w;u<8yn0+Qx(>pJm1CJf;+#91K7sF8+ z<<9-Brzm`&B9hso5rslC~&tJuS|dGFebZQ~9{$crCMu4n9`GL5eB2Q!SmzW92>$(ZK% z={H4gI8|XML+1;b>Ki_WaVZA$F=|BFL_)kHV&~zn{rQD>1J&GD(j3(n;3Cov`+De0 zN9;9Bypsn8dr4*=M`B*eRKPSQ4?ybOxB=wjXp6*O6K;qO!H3BEMB^H#@CzoV?Omn= z+#5_%X-US>t?6n5Y+pJpLBtg*7{~Sd??%ldL*ZNVCTB^lRqK3q*vq5P5l&3Aaik(} zhPa}sxh>tKvb(<0vYy|@>nNfmv^r`U-DnlSKK<6f<a~RQf`+G3pGNsVvN_l;RZb ze9smqx_g#g%6z&qER58+(i`MnJbN$3K%(~x1}wS!ZWneK&V#qs7d~!+h)+{ozBqhebCOnKT6_#cXRQza3*>c zUnjwHH&pOG=GCe;F>&XbA`vZjLo+D9bKVH zKi@77NCq%7;qA3cO)d*ADuI&<@XRaA&(Y?w^=qs6OT@puIrJ!2J-4R6VZ4a7m~hc;7yO~|Lud{4`Rm%PujH5@V$!g;?kSBkLobLR9ZJVfT#`0?)5mSe(g`~?sKx6(v^qM6a{Lv%dhgA%-DGpw#>zvjzeSE& zFqfkkh*&z_rcdA@<6lj4!*dIGOq&kJ`9u*7FcMTC_bIEi_7@7Qv~~6Gd8cf@RP$>q zC=!6ZOU%RkDa=?lqKE7Rxz(Q?}A&dd2@)YMg%GU8ic02+tI zuPpCFBjZDFk-J}A$Dy*ISJk+C?g)EJwnG_$I$(55aqL(4H1NRp%U4YgqOkN5K_kRenA zW*hX(5ZO;bt>BzxMVq)mornl<^f#zgeO8F% zxL6{)@(K<*YW=6{@n2N^X%o0R?MI9HZfV5zK8&oL>Jg&#n+lq%_S6b*g&E(+yonQV zufv_~@8rV3kA8#C!JDE0B(7`PVt5xBTE0zRA$pPCX^6NF-II1XDl=ov7V~PYp0R{I z{Od;LdL&mqA^)1x)xkh8EfQn&3~B~Sdf-mx7rDO3PILZs-KE`(?BQg$N(&X8oa)#}OMuOi`d)Ei$hE0`pNA6Ybq(zEvbti4M6_3k;>dNs zL%#*q#c)uit!WA(o*Oiv9d>{`$WD2*f^)rVGe1Ppw{`q^OQC{JTY%hIGgR-WD#u$v zC;@=Itf_6rr49j_rX4LA_&EDVILtgcWj+5^nygE(cpB<=Imte~bi`bmjJZU}a`8zY z+diXLy4`6|j&iO|TD?>Jdfuc(s=J%9MR$wA^7_U0cy-6e3CUd<|~6UbNHMnfcO5J29AMnYLFvIYCq~Sb34O zAf5QFOXRfZLUW<9=@KoMBv&gf+hhHz@0|7vnpSXx#ZV<0zQkZYa7K%2{&lj%Ey71} zww^p{9ZF1?PnZITdSmZ>XwCpI`AsrQIh!~#&8foqZqzPkZnh&f(ptMa2yhq?%pt;i z!Js&8+TxDbyS01Wl`y6>6s(hyZ+3bk)daYb?aBs_MiKhvd($6|;2#xK9bnIuNuAb7 z1Hz!Yay^Aw`bKO9VDA|MKme*2)`udCPlOubVzW$ZB}4W@$yR)GwJ_<`&AN}ISnFO| zvDbrYfeJ4Z$<|}{Pl#rC6?!r;$F=0$NXE=1nfq!-q~QR-ToL-n{WY|```BzHzM#Xd5=N3FM|4BZo48aOr{C1ZRa z(M^;@YEnKUp(Y?$EJL$@ryM}TFZ1|LKB+@v3oRLL(~zVk%GiP3>!RPA+G8urTYJ|R zhL@z{hxg-b#b@Fk@gj|y{|{QZ_Kj9 zkCO&o3bNcsYpDGWW?RyVr36b^?~Ba-{l`lm{Vnf)u~6T;m5O# zB?{2M-AB2tN2`wvN1p(sN0i4$P%oj-up^-wGQzQH&K}b~o_;EFfUfb&jr@W^K_hTH z4BeD|-Li6pUy-u0Hq1944GX(@iQ)osgC-Ry`E@#C!899QH@e&7-8X8ug?{Exf#j^u zI5F>I(n7~~Km3DkG1PvPaXMOii(q6i@IU|oknGge3@g6a(umf`){<(R4p#Du&AL5W zyLzkSBXi2j?`Hx4MmE95gvc;YLL3J797-K|k>lok$ zo6?10rYrPzU=03ivk={gb8&33$EA4SFT$9B+sga)Y=dbo*O4 z;BZ@{xw~cNtbCly1iL!_;|m~i*MTv$@WY}!Jv&>N5*ad|(7^TS@j(NdK6VB3dTtZCH5UE3WE zt!ZATArkw!cQV1}BcNm44Y#l#H(ZIZkgn--7e4Txad^ylIg&JD974{JUY3%*cETy_ z2sd4wTW&;I3P@{lKVq&SHsSQ=3-8gjs}A=eMTdr3sH*JxT@W zMjmn?#I*|7L~0@7ugA9Mv)Rr4@{GKV|8UxU&2hvj>moKyzK4~Hqk}c{1%A7mDBJZk zfabRRmY0YRCJBLzXp3Yk>?5jO35rqQ7mx3-D!LdpID40Z06X{5xoM~dhgD0im$L9f z1MSi^aC^Jq#|wH4A3J|OSa@L8oRRS$Sg>I;X)ET>3}!?Wy>pS zxW4DG_mDqzGsABl_eGS%#jn9NnR)5YZA5mcgg&{Mryc|@p1ykk{9XcU z0_lq5VF8u4=HQzvpCha0fXJypcn^F|8X`Fwk!-{bk5J+v(Hiy<+5?u@EA6fD2K4u~ zuUr!gUeLNEyrNU0;JqZcVV(MXD8v+n?CZE>QT2&LwsZKicD&!|QMDF{o$Z5DmcW7H z8BT@o9rU?3nT-g>s^8sfN8Y~f59!0Bis^WQzM4<}3*tS7(QnL&BOi$PeuQr-MnnM7 zOph$o#Lh9MQXFO}Z*i0ezOox`-wBV_bx^!IZ9|<$B(kNM4b)iK9o5K4{D{INK$7Ys za7S2b{lV6?;nj(gp0asM&OXdO50rCyNYV>dnTX_G0DgI^fMviXz8;NBM0#iXD*I== zTkf5grjcY7VnF@Uceaj=ARx?OD6bz`5R*W4*DF53Rx-=rC1{ER{iTeJ6Y)&ZqB_k@eOg8GF=*yfu{g3R&|56L_2hy(i4 z((v@_EqKS5O(!M5cFJP>bqpyg(qkkoW{*P%3-^QLe1Ow;P!q04qtBLV)TfMF!`wSpGv$2~V?U;1LTDL@v^mNEyfz(2^ZJ4g zuV)0y!0j1&fcBEBvGE47>i+FdrQlBU$U*8X{*rNXO8H-$pXFtQ^#oF|QKmYtZ1u*n zGb%{F2L#^~yxlQCR+6rXrOufEf!8%8@ZQ*5(@3!L=jr5hlqr0c@ZWfY2TkQ%$d!Kf zt9HBqy19f4Q`x{1HLdN)3YGoE!KEO=x3(Fz;ttys1+1jfx*v_1#U%c_BfDJ)UF=)_ z8|mmNWOCekAkp+%nD<=<{+Ob|b_l)=B5Fzlq;EEqpqT!sNpjAWcBoTF~X845y$F;L6o9)QayShMqeLa0oX{V5a z@G(w$toUlKjjK`h&6wAy)}*?P+dC>4Q##99g(C*;x71Ws4sPd@MP7*_SwQ$RsthEj zeH^_VhL(=L1mpn`HlYGT7Z|C$5vB~?n5!m#KDeSh3k8GOmKr`ocSTam(0Xovlfv^4 zbqhNWSA=WDaP0vbIcIvsBaAmJ>`hZ$RSu6jh5y<|K(GR5Exq{&Phj`!NHu3RJS+&;9&Mo=JzY3S zVtHKv?2Ey&7lfr4%Fs5uS)H{lUd?INM~&QX6EXbM=FWD6)cH@jQ^W>Cg$%R9s?N}> zvWIdQtb7>a>ZjoNqUsY2Q;EiXnH~qqxW8ro;PBsn%&8?GO}#UXmk@T>j;f9+FQ%oM z71gztH2CrLcrrPF611|cMu%uTXl$VIovq^v^G=9*0>zyYO^m9bwa+(Ri=8%7#L4UN z<22H1+u1M1s&!OxgmhtAnq&^r*NN+dvz%%`l9-tCjjHP1VhD`9q?C&%7$!)xJpaD$ ziXag!k?`}Yj^r#_A#MRW(-ByaDFf4sQknCD2YT4XG&gAbZNM%wDzI60S%lI zTi=DeJc|%Y;ZhS#50jn9D-7eA=;AB=Sa}AF2|*VQ5>o(94ZIy?Of+S@4(Q6#&;5my zW@0jaS1G!=3EBp@Umdrs-4n_JNh!+|+`mHg}i!#gTKBoJvKn##(5u?=@ z?+V0!r&*C;BfJik7;nN_0P%6aUPqm1r;-CIu!C# zc}~$ynCnt!(alEsU2~1Z?%?wv18D|2=LG`kHN_m7lapN>qfVqUEV!T@{Z(vN6Pef5 z{wK3$#mpP$u``_SJ+et(E~3&>2SgGY+U`2r=e>dF;{d5=+5aro4pHg7= zD9vG};Y)D<@K6fyd8p|TSx`1Fl7-r#l|H?NLgO4o8b6CzO6i4X%!$o?MwI*g-hY_=#LCXJ%(4O!_%M8EArtY(fZo_~8I`pAO#Kw!S zFQj1N5lZp+C3#}&heP%ryQe;TFa`at%SDVqdGK*_y!{D^FF zgPhCIDv^*d53f~+R^v!)yUo@i*nrA(6P9b?UcvmHn4?NN6t(xFlC;GN!EO$9{sPw8 zqQ&aNa@BcF5p4BB$lU9i!7p=Tc1gi=I&E3rcvforO*v}W@9gH}=PzDZTXb6K&%bQ5 z;-Am?B~Te~^}b}-R2{CruJ8L8zt@6VDUZntLf8%e#=Ra6I=>qUU`XOECM_Y7f$FN}S%yB3#%aHL9gUXywY|c!SyU%)8_opUWbe!q_hKkcD6I?dlg5uL z&RpKn3OT=L{rNKV8v^mAr{UcNF~wLcr1##4PQoX2I(DGi*(+{ix3zf-wRw$BvJ)fA zkt`b>KLd!)&qGvMb|SVmInn^-+UpRp>EyP_$L?Ut(ft7`$*jb)>9E1nQ`gNMFYz*eGwqpm81(N% zKQ0r8*|uz%@#C(MAB-f6%Kru#dqXSR7kL*YD-q2VC2cs_LloVWJ_=zWl5e*Ngojw3 zy#fkviCf{!cr%=^tP?WgBt~_N%9Q%^1rkdxzZG8}u&V+8tcOw_QZ>Lgg?B4OZ(t_} zqIVa@e7FBuGrc8d9FCiYMHiyfm7SlI{~p-Hi(CmRBW#FOpXBC{DPVIkORjjOZ#iR| z7O$IayfNBt@^M7j+nrbdYh-y9;s6NU=%7lq_ZW@t$}u)wlpU}pWO z&d3Vc_}&;g*3kvVF2NTYYYc&{kBp0S`H>VkP%99XL|MBD?&Y?mM%T?arZx*Pg@=Tg zexg1}<3U?}jWy3oU6<|;pW);k4F9Qay0L&bKcpuHt51@$nhUya5;#c-r#ErUvi`_VKT51UsO3`SpKK;5 z3`SSs+e}ouVoF4ToC>{DB~K}c7-E%A>DdsF>MF>8&tj&9Yd{wJ0jm*xt#W8JJgmHb z&@kaB?D+lR2?>;qF~*o6q8Vby7eZ*W@sY9&;|e6lV77!UX~D8y*C~SLO{m3a%czW5 zY=VH-bgGrb0z<)_>p{A7TymB6c*ZWTLn|J1F)EZhCT>ntj;!bmXPD^>zx`VHAcj5h zb5u4M598($pe4yTl35}h4%xl7?BoWq!$HOD_$449u-Qgcxh4$r7)vJW9Nr|)iRvcyUdQmdPM-G zWW#S*YW;a(>Kjddv)iK&a~)!GC4(7D?}71ANqdMK-f`17t<7qcY*};g@E`?AUu_Oe zp781pf}g%E4!GA9Wh_26WBk$nJcu$&eo0WTEKiYklNLxzh9cwLtEgy;9K?(BacCNo zjgUfLs)pPux>5kAgqixI{9Ui2(eP@U#r3lWd0i!20fF& ze{-~d=-p?~SjgDH&>mvzXk-7I{C$>W^sSyiVp(Z^SydT2etU?%rL@vNnIigD5KC9U zo8LO^AK6mh^a&LP|5HZb4`s~2#>N6*UOUvM{!Tnk z;t32k1_Pei;eTa`pDF79w!xp~oD3X)6VysiwDPlkeyald4#vNE?Elps5PJtlK{I{( zzb7xH|5q9WV*6eF-z^OIy#{}RK-l`})C9!Z6u_hkvF5jSfc!1|uBQqyax`=Ji`0IO zod5q98{0D^&JKRYs-LLu-`?@Rwf1+3|1IxXdkXJAe@{#K_w%2!;NNYtKIuRJ2Q%|O zxzDA3*L=zWv$OwU%byr=8)a+A^N|t2^EUCXtMlI;`b@Js{I-ZB#OT=`&n+taL#aDG z1MdHVii7?KzJDUkpAMruxi#R8p+3ak1^{9Nu`qG~-k3Q$+P-6Y!tS3$Q+s_|Gl-!B zqm8{O?H^~Bv$rvFGJHDR@_(=PKREsqOaGt#C8+=8>o%sp=kR+re-ZirQ_02N*aZ10 zJXnyQqU5g&z{bkT%nC38{Lw&QPUa`$JYN9ozce6_gXPJ(|DgdvPcHr+8VBfUpZ+%u z1ZD+2g~q>WKp-c}(}MiF1_C{;+rMid5C{0b+5>U0KAHaC>Vm-FCtvt4?b#>(qZ}va ze`(C1r(NTpa*p=;Ptk1u`z(?o#Lf8GR?m>Xf{o47`v1=v1#xSWr*;14{D6a_zP;mb S>w=h{=7CH_B`hm~{Qm$?oM`3% literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/figures/instrumentedinteraction.svg b/figures/instrumentedinteraction.svg new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3fbf8df --- /dev/null +++ b/figures/instrumentedinteraction.svg @@ -0,0 +1,278 @@ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + image/svg+xml + + + + + + + + + + + Action + Command + + + Response + Feedback + + + diff --git a/figures/logo_cristal.pdf b/figures/logo_cristal.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6e5e40505d5380ef654f93584baaa53119b37613 GIT binary patch literal 3417 zcma)9c|25Y8zzM&)QFT9oyK068DlqDXDG%t21U|f#y-Q$kUdL!ZDmP9WGB=pYa}%- zgvze6BvFzrTZH&#w7k9F_s{qI&hI?uT<5v(=f1A{`Qtj0<|qSsxPmfBvU-}n20{QZ zfb8fFLLvbuhCp(mxdKW|2nzxL0BYdoNh460vnQTLKoOkC&IFK_7Klot5b$0g|ICmy zV4l*$?9onP+pKp9CR6y6F>uUYL!;}I$IzE>YxMB3!YaA(Ku0ycvR+A@}~ z?X=#hp^ObgvYF=Q`sjK)d18IE+$pteMUC2MKp#(_wk=hRjHlVq{Wg;6DN`bT%GYWa zyEH?-${!rpJYBlHP~}@-w;Z==6y-uM>abr8HFS`7@<5X2e9uwZW(RWQ$#%6xcDC96 zS;LotKObzgeK4QtGGSxFD@}e=u98uJ{k|A*@vWpukN-W&;Tw0r?n4S@X~c!n;P~#& zj}zZ2W{P{uRP8_ZNiY|3n)0%I{ry~}NM8$2xuv<%rvwAHH!kM;_DJyPd5YBX}i{&VoTIRC&gpyg6t@skEriqCB``~QTua+&5G9PDjD@X+<(HN*~t27XE} z#tcT68_aE#1fohN7SaT&NpqiZtBPOwHcmKep-->4-?9%VFU?eX`PPQl(W^aV2$w#Z zK32QO>iMFPlwr;-@EK&*b{~DP=v--72JsVRB%gCNQEG-fS-Xf8%RJ+i-e0wZV*^u& z`e50K2toYkz*91ZyN=ksH0^zH1GlT7xL>GZ&?M$Pr1#pf_Rf9biQIQ~hl8l$_FhFY zd<>5yl%$dqlE34)*wp;&Vn)fb@WZwMJ@vtyst6l7i}56vU zfqV{cv9NWHQm*!6O;dGp(i(1&4Yl^}yGU5WK1C~}ThJL9EDZ2jM7$MhGaU+e2Sl7f&>eCw)pVVF#!C*D~8UHt4CsQwu6WIE01 zeKPe3kcY9M-XK8jOf5>kHZgMsys-~PpYLL%>1wW31<2F`Mu+_(Ld zP?MrJa3s-`J=Uz@*1Bb{w1p~KFH6{V=>24H!+`YcIq$TS&X0s(EA}Qlpwab04vfa* z><84xa!>E-yp|RXll`EzAIxR>ARpc$_sFB>K!sygg-ca>&(6gC4P{(z^h1V-E;oqY zps4zZAlD+2e@(s9VI2(_Cv@5_3SPd7jGE83i^_J;iw~_ z6mGj@Uicn_hRuo0pLF6=GD*x^c&4tWvJ$lC1}c2-_G8iz*;fVjFOHVE?9bff<0#7b z#8a=5^cT^Ox29qD`rl=my5cV$1;J5Z$P*jT1tM3{Uwyjz!Xc@PvF3eW0}f;J)q-Ml zEqsKgjjZCN3hR70`~C9V!@wz*AKy{1!x*%}=`nkI@4H-*;K)qlxJEgh|76Z%DKP(X zU~I`9tY!o^N|N69{I9M<{r9WOo5fPf&oZ*>CnOg5drgjeI;_w}ED`J+xML&I$D%V! z@~^r!9<|NE%%+!;;4LlH?3l9Eah?a2?v0$&7Ew(FIOGK$6E#qG*i^{}Hdlu5Mjxf! zqv{^!#+fU*&n(6)Ma6d|#%Jcmxd$fNZuFozTHu{Pi`4`~ zGqMq@WIej`sF`mw#xgP+b6Y|km2S=O6uGpK7wrYaG4!>%Y z@pJwvcj8H3SMec}m69V$LHEEHU+We5$<5h$-8V;d>(CEvxO(!tv`SCgD(L`C! zqR5O6jO!gR-(1U3o85DB^n&Bc7#&Z`A zm9u)4f6s|L)Ymk;MTi}8Mjf>M$?TwwZBP)ad%@ z>j8t^(Y-<1CJgy53CCqzk4}3v`((wfn@ykz*=C-ygI*8Y1)w?;)!T)o)4|8-?5~Ll z*p~hj_J^MEeth~L~B3f7LYC}1`%{PGc0s{d+_D~`C&d{=SpE@gypq0 zU0I{tVJ?)_d5h7j#Uh$z9^wqbJAStw)2{isx-Z{zV)K@<=C=MFMlJ8(RW4UF-Xx5q zmi1L_oD8zJ9QxEeUQp1hf8C}jK6Eq5@@B%?wN2Ni+WZ?k-c*`yo)I~r{Vk-ia(5n= zESqF#>otenY1r0v&$-$zyN!(nmqyVCV&^#aXzS{N2qfp9{*L*?a)vBB$eNjkP*EAK z%38pBRs3xnx2z)CpJr%DW7^;=%scb?nMe6| z9sr69@FoCIbG!>-E2lZ0LLkwYVZZ#S3BlP7uSfO=?3fS?P*PD=P)4XJ!x4bGl7fP~Yfr2Mdy;&PO1^j}K12l^7 zR!J;Y`pi`*f}fic0c)toTJnPw6ic9zeJM@^D!`Hk`v*l90hVMeG5(=Q-73`B&6&!i z!%_kJyLMj|>pv2x{EAh)W3LxWzccYL2xB^^BK@E^`rO~`KpiGsSpbG`>?ds-4 zRUlJbWM#LuF{hB7eVv$I{{IjAr$wrNZ2zNveLM~CNp|^>n%OSu&nEp7<4++FK`=lK z1p7Sz6=h|FGC%}=Vv6brrZTJnkbYw-2&Q`f#$YfwQ=WfgiYhSm|G`vY%(MDm>(tem z;{6*#z!jON;ul7v;N3h4l&$7ix&;!LC9}GWC6j3Yi};VjbDTsZ1FSY|^_5D)Q)pWZ P5pY%JpOhrp%mDNsl?BP) literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/figures/logo_inria.pdf b/figures/logo_inria.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5c5a4e4390f0dd8172c0178ca185f5c0eff5d113 GIT binary patch literal 30478 zcmbrm2jJ7x_BgKMR@@75d;mctKvuIDAL&kan(i>uHtEW0o37wS6ja>vi5qbb#DNQO ziwkip=u`2D8=R>4^mjikZl3Rb|Nm-BJ~#KCd(XM&o}G;3T%K|0cxv#-_tvd?Y4EO8 zAJV61%Y!FPf`cVZ5^E((%J-pgun$LU6b(oE7}(uMk~R_!gXTDB#xNVq_D$_02(k~Q zkm>#XgC#9L0HklLpTX^#BoC(gP<$}5<%5!a-K#!r@UB~$C~PZj^k3Rg6hr?!7NrRM z&utja0MrIPzs-Ro)L-D?6iWZOpADz~G6#X!{xX)J5$4ZhNdo`NT95%s{kj&jCYBVb zHbC(hAa);yz`U-TeP9`VJnYkCy$|#rxO7dO#831PSMbgq?z@pC;-vN0}A#2!FvAy));8)E~gLeuCQ<5 zEDSUboJ4*)?5yd=-%b&d@+I+advIb6tYHh%yj0g4wVYH3{N`?(-k1q?5L|m>NZ$bK z_woJU16XjNy$^xo#fF;g>n;?I*GlT&&eWyo0EvGiXBY7;d$AR!*}^UaiT}nW?0h92 z(AFZmzqNV4`%cK5dv*UL`>XB)C!er-@#%}Eyt#SMv3D+dw!IkX`(ouHSO0Mr$M-$& zfG7VEdg+SSK6~aFDtz1V)Q0o#x>k7V#*tTzIrm%7BQN~0DM=rT+_dPd!vdzK&d}+gHBYfFowtFr(>fG3Kiv}P3-X9leMdgb^FQTe+~B9Q)}V7p4Q3f4M{|U%l^;%*B@m z_dd{%jvjpH1Kh_SNA~*k!pLLDyn9X`K4YP6+M1if-@krxP2cx%VM!7?lG}-?e{Og!Li_9XWp>Wv%|&=n@R1m?b|m^nsRpO`yKHY*N#{=oi}(7rXY&pmhd*-ssI#|hUAJN&6Ds+Y}s zG?_j8r$eKam%jMo-R`PUZ{4@_S?^-92~z zFFu;};bYhL9lhYaed2RFfd@|B`O&5DL8H`5g2?9+FBz*&-gNgn8>MNFEbYhKH=g>| zX4k9-UD%;RJp1qd%~1=NPqdWm1MsKM$XEUA$w!_!XTBHy^rkDG9X>R-=RY6Z?7Hq~ z=j>&7?|h7ZUUvKZ=je7v{P6CC?Sz{y+S_<|_3hyI#C!JM>)O-KjsASdw#@?y-(vq- zO8aS zGx+>5d%XARs!d;%Uv@mSdj9ki7I;>FdgOV}pD^>aH-nrKHC?5anrFV#L_c(I%JYw`aca45(Xm0xZcVBQy;b!;X9fr?%cF(}dwTEN- zP_B)oOJY)L>8GC{wRc0OT(DNWytDm7E3f(Z!qfh_vb9)x>yiU*310U8%ExT|7#d!( z?PT|e)YacE`o8hwq~i`b{`q5G+n87LYxnBNS9fMSbk?+o&%5)Y0~cr8wM{`%UcTgl zvGZ3x%k|~bzVRRJz3`f^r)g=JfzFM0$dR#5!zUlqs{Pi1; zdE=IA_)&+As6Ib7j^2M@_QrorJaI8O?87k|X3Sl_Y@eH+2p#o!ZTjmsT&3T8miXj{ z#)tc?SYZ2Oh`+%+R6$;u^fy!yaR_b%(3OiFNk z+ov0M+R!^DM5b&`7H*xoKQ0}fEa(>>dH(1Tk;K7~%_m*>#MvRo*$?s`k~cl|fb!x! zC%;V{w0=l@^6V8z;dE*7F<I*?|E=q+Krc&%5KEurere&nwnXpMSFMhsKhIfL%It@Zk$q zUa}^)PpkCvamNo{GrUo{;(Kv?WqC1p*7s}P90Xs1{=DvoHS|aKE*Wykm&NDvpZ)Z} zd-X}^^!x13et6g{ZHIH-JnqEJ*-xK_N87M(9}msP58M6ez{|HPt8S%DeHqX8 zwVfN2Prh`!<6)FksqFO$>JxE`fT}6`C$)z|M_Vj zUA*D4czpTP<0ox6V$|xv(+7Qe=q>1`8}Gd7um?9hHB@-q5n_gpS$4%{T<_r1hqI4|dJ|AMJngxkJ7>h}m!Rl}vNg{l}a*_1*XPz5cdsZQ?#VE05g`-Sp}= zk0oyY^vr{fnsa4odF~_TmcFNp_(89-r(c(fc!u1(>RjQ>XD&Y~JGFfWak(tc+t`mj ze?Z`XqxZTP*=}O)t2=MJe$O#`|9IHH_gT7R_i%XC`-;Kb^pE-L=t;ScknrIjzrWwb zg_m}ZJ@8HR`X{0A$D5yeXyOicoc-h5>)W5)A3LnE_t&ZQ^_!q~hrAy>`|uZbnSPPy zIoHI4+gDySYM1-A>mNV4dgswY50B4n2nQef^6GcOlW#lW#IHWI&z*3P{M^z|@9i=otH-rc8=_Kk;DW#fQ#*c*nJB=LT`rRo>9!o22)PS2#{NCoLYf zdGt@07CwIU{oB?Z9^DMD*k&)s&OdL3O$W65e`QmG`h$wjpC33AsA$)KsC?n%?_OGe z5Hsh*zSEx{zUiNf{O8Wz@$wLL#Sy3H&pF@s*}C0V3ad7W=kX7GP#a7vbmn<>6EI|76j}lUBb{Y_09P{JzgVX>U9ApF3ag+xP)>b7cL)b7xH0 z^hoZMX^Ypb9&_Nh!ROpqtUQJuRE$qMW#Wi?KX_DotU- zy|Cb)cIcz$j1>>)n@{pT_r$2tdo5@#x#fHx^hNaP9qxFLI(gZSu_wQ|zWQSQRx46H zeZNmGz23cjpSjqx^o$E4x1BN^Ur!OA47&FG%kfPoS;?c`zBsX3o%!LlJ3f5iz02Oc z@31us?K7UdGqu};IxFq5_XP)!em438cH5wB6H_<7eZo68KmOw(#~*&uS8wYlKSe&X zrqDVT`s5oWz8l(fHIK=C`^xoW_n5uzuJJK;9W|?b^=IXSue)leLB|ZcCV9o{+|eU$ zeRR)5mZdIwYX7gkT(KEhEZ(`(v1@O>X3uHEjx!oNxo3@GCcgNfcImOve=kKpUVHt* ziDc~3f4O7(UAS=069-MpprLtp%H^|G$KE+}o4)Cd^LHHigSE@^uUY+X$11NJe#VYx zY&-U!W4{}x_+KV7AHFvsCq>tOFyg}H>bFxLeI0gOfnV~1x;(j2!Cw4q=$unl&mMlo zrF-78lJqUlr%US(zF1nd{*HS>H|@lf?)`@Oc{gO68_ivw+X@E`Sit|C0~y;N1!dsY z_mQ2~uHWz8DN~;~=8Ut@!o06-r@waky+6yl2EXht-;mhTeb(DS~ZbLyF2-FVOS=ZszWLVCr0qkfvZ zXk+8+#mVir9XI3SIk9IO96n=x;2*osIVq)M>z|vsZ0@F+Yv=u2JZDw)n-3nWwu`zGg%9>b12Of;)4^kkIw2G zz3_oE&$?prf!e3@u6+CTy*7NroIEs2KKPF7#OTV()Gtmy_=6LcK7Wa_;Pw{t_RxLK zJ*EEcZe`yM2i^GMvUd(StT}YWvDE{X%_1C)iTmr%-6w_~di)>Aiqkqv!*pT!k`+tm z-Ia;YX%o*5-DUBkhb_L{zW2i~jC_B;@x;)Xr#=!IvzVSgw0zEyJ4&mAZ%upV%e%;L z$Gs#^eChI258ZRl#&P>zb=vTa`*}Wh{oD7|rWTx7y=i0Fef2l5JTv*L6(9O{Km1?m zXYYM){^$9JZy$Z*Uh^*bCNbxwOJgkV-TsVG`#-_4EvSxwn3E)|eu{)Bp4h-z{FbZok}#FJ0gFVe7b84|;cXZo#wnZNBV- zto@V&cY|G1PQK&L6DGg<(~m$f&boNF4O?N$0gvo|U`yaf|Kj1Y^9S_zP;}=9RzY8H zd($?Gy_ zuc3DjKiPIH(r`aFVY}0x`~1`AYNy=XdFZ9Rj-B zug^TMb>>D7Le|6s)((n3{TBA>)uGv6KggbS2^*Mu<-r1TQvBk@*Tr`jJ#px@)#&{* zkME}*UovdBRYN>ePWkctpNh*6aeV8lrhwr!3N%Pk;o;~ls?>&6Ujc?puoIUdJDf{jE{$9K6u=sH8sIN^tz#E&-Iwmx#lzOzc7?{n8}cY1Dk#bX^ixpvIt2X8*;2K0G0`syJi_ozpXA9B~Tr{8c=Y5z|O>~?FCdk=E%clI`CUVo$a-6c05m1{!> zqRrzkq|SMD$merD8noioM|PUECV0qC_Oq!)Up}_y1^>8Uhkq}SUjF9p8Id(Ry>ick zZ>$}6vnP33X{dhanB|8}c<$9#uAlSpiSNBEg};0^7e410?#}49GlaRjTzAo3qXXm_ zXJR+Kc=c%)lJmc|1@63X!WkD7Adc*7m7u&?};9A`wws2H1>wrOK+}u zW})-o)$(1A61Dy9w>6UU-yZYR|bC0GLUV8A?ANmh_>WIx_Do*I>7gyiz zxzx6+G4qVQ-V4mxK6l^2hmP9m)U$UQy3eA@K9lbqy!pH9-amgub}Vt~;>+Lr;kcbo z%DuG9_j}*J_UdiUbUys>$Z_MY=DBM#(M!)=ynJWdjn5vn&yZ{OU32TO6WDY1Y5Ja? zGi=3ftzlNxKh(d+vA5jXIsLV>hJI@veV=T* z;LtZd9ro7d8$LVa7oe`dzK$5-}WKfid*_iJ8$aot;=eiwRh{k=`~y!~IAFMf0d@TrbEbq{MRtpB?R^?!~hk;I?;`ui6gf$r}5_nD4e zY{QOo`9x*+K@0DB;$IuqUSk!Wq|ZQSoqolQS>KrYs^)cPT&(&|zGvcNv&ln$bjMcS z{_TA`k4xPjYHnJ*D13C|6j9B85@S4kid?|TJU`_beyY4@I z4C8v{=EQ0HtWMpc%7be^Pn-GLKNsKf)jG3riTyKU$m|oo*nH!88=jHShaa0DIO2?%2flOn6{D7)e*RqYqW(MIa({N^ zZF}VTrKg|y@WN?lpMT{P`>ES)I(&Zr5tDA|9C!uVf5i2d_21~;@v?0mY`naJdHo{o zqmMS6{qW5z4xh4$Id8Wq2Toly&X;6-N4@>ZOP(*n6T&MOj6Uk7C(yz--|uk~I_I_Z zYj;tXoIBR~`d?S{Uvi!9zwfn$FRnN=@j!msZY=WYGiTn?7r*SHwD*IRPot+VmG3#& z%757_pViGhpGJtwqe z^K48yF1zc6{=(b(6W9y4jaW71;d_V7P7blYyl#Z+jUn+xqGN|spRBGv^r`FL+$Q7s z=^Xji1BO0x)pN+hZ;dl%eYVq`jc3>m%{wnSO}g^}*X<9z=DNRqNM>qk$c$YBn;va$ zM%yQ@>JLBi{=sh*haP(<_OBJKX@gE$x%s?ve7Dh047q8W@t3#{zv6o|-5jzGWrO?d zyJO|DlWzVwzoxPN4gFas^W?oVD1Gh)bBEoqZd-}ib?~=u?6PUY7jK>eo&H+#kU7^? zd{eHUTbw*-!}Yfc3y=J8{eCl_zwzNsb5AlB&gPo^Cx8FmH;=Da@Xt4HQjazcoV9WE zmHJ+nKl%J&i;g?&uo-7p4;%aKkM}-0Gqw5172B+t`Qr~;;pyMStL?s6pDZeM33i0w zuwGL|1$Nr|(D4Wy;kMj~a3PR;iP`(iT0??kA+cToT{RF*8Hi~A8r6k!Vt1Tw^v3-z zD7!^{Oa=LcywsNRuuE!|auV-#^kD?i*9}ikA6V#slKD#%V=8QqIek8w*b@2wT^3;a zF9`q}M*n6N(G%0tBmM4bc*@8lkBrQmGE$myw147Ah#t*I{praeo{Sw`nvp5k@yXN2 zv#zvfJb#4Z3r-ns_#rnpdL*)Ib~-7R)v%zA88-RINK}xbGcsewPM&_WbG!qZmQV^z zzUUe=yyToZam-|Vmd>G5hs9JnWRIlO_)vK_-uCxEyKCR~zr?*Li_*DI-I{%(U@G=let2uH?ulrf1|Z?>XWK zC=#9oP3IGS)rt5fm6hOlJzc5`6JwdgRG1nuX%tS?a!NE%mHg6(u?Y{w7qaNC$#BXO zkoz^4V2i}-NNiYL^!9tbfrJtr6Fu5SOmO-}+5AV&#LAN-)9-VZDT&g!PJj8TaQ zJ84%gLe-}E#ZG0^EN@I#A1H z3`B#{%1kXWCNg?gW$F=RSc8O_;VLq{P8I9ZXQk7qCeWi8n>g*bZu0Jr*_7Xf2OK4{ z&Pg?=t{Q;fKvIE*ow}meVuqNL`nt&txF?nWmPc5rR4AGt1NaNKpf~}iN_mht!vDxN z9%Sao;pnIlX{`}DvR~5!L0c$QO-?=9?bAcfS(Ad5qsDlIFPVYFmBvpj zDkDLHYyv;UF^qJU*|EyjDDpdZ)u}fC8BjP-%Gak3hj=GQbx{kJ3cJ6B>$&I7}6 z3WsBjtT}LM)1hE*+%E~M-%ih@quYSI70K+&N`;a(dH9C=9~$0Q%1<7iB0@;Wa7x7z zYt^Kf6^`euN{-17Ke~U{N$m-3)lfnDtFNspT75!$@^BHHXK4bs9%zP#_jS9NmC3{H z12_88A+FD<*Q7pTJUK3h;#42Sj7JHEBI&UpFNu;cLc=IJ4#g*6wh1=um-O!N{$0W4 zq*`8{z`HzKrUQRX9$qv}V*(7fTCMRde7s&Oz$n8oFoMAtHV*U{SMO-1*dC|VNA!UF z0>>rQbG4FTmUOLe0IrzT8|LKU!v`k%_0z*EpZj$lqft}3v*dHIq)6&O>J3K6qwv4SK+p3fI-NA8szn-4Ofu9CX-xqsQk9#ud$Nvi{H0*tm59s<1J{d+K5pWpZ$lmCH~;0C}L-|AL^d*Cc? zZ371G{KsKHuMeP5_kf&o3|vXS!WcMS(w4hj4(=ZBU;Dwo9xZTkCgpPzq7>=z9~ zDdoh0GX{g1C&9nn`i(>b{mqi8NZm93>(T2TcDrK!v2_6cz-d)V143YeB5Gh`+vD<* zEH)H#cz;Q&%>>DIeP%sZ0!&qsOVx%n6I2Y$tTnSUo7g0{H~NoId#!(*th?AhuWJ(6 z#tFa3PZ!8v_XD9tjYF7mC>=+s3E+Q(gb-{3f=q({()V{bckk)>lHB>9p#0YJPcWRI z>;cqA{0}SnUC*t-&}(sBSNeNm+V|VB>vK8>1T)n)Iwa;wnyJ@|NA*za0^Bm}PY}B) zeGOEd)c-{10pkCW%)R~oWlsn08)B_44G5aa!+()9zh|%C7-Zl`0ZBQbHK5k}F@o%_ z>vv7Rt?I9Xid_Stp8*{43!E)Ye>Z9iU;8m8X>#g7Of~@JA~M~ABP?EANaWKqeist z6YbG~!Qd0MJ7CCWcU3%A8i z6oM|h9&onwKo_9PVGp_Nt$}aUWw&u|I~{R3LUE5H8h5u_S#P_ZW81X+>$l}*9j#p0 zWk)h#hK#qE;61$Fz261+YscRY`X8@h8Xy`i*wX-Ad&|xDP`3Mcdo;uY)ZBK_H-IJ! z$lw6q9?IR{sK?&&c>!5ir@aEu1NRC(*Pr|K07mUjfGwa)&gYEkLD1C+CUDscQ732v z6aj#=5ZJ5`@37l}UGHm0lWwmYbC+@%cOqnXi;i}x9W8N=F2IDz7DH{JL_7ITq3Kql z79X!v1Dy=cIm3ylRv{x+xR_4}Y}|!3d_KP(@;i$Kq38#stHzL|8BPWqwT=zu++BcZ zB#sE_6!3vkXgi-)n3RAO4N*1g*%Z;t;5?ew@-``LP%?``G9GakGa_5^sezKM6E5qJ zvqHp@iXmlGp$o8@)%=*G5rMK1NT~){GOE=^y(W@PowwV40DYg!5e4iL&A6R_A+iIs zExJMBmpc|pxIGCzT=W%$c0q7=x&ZYo+wz21-WCfxJxPBl*K}Kc7w;+*#aN<~DrKmk z(}8obu;h0a+WADKRp_GZFAE-TDPPHZ5;$FrSglUM=mJC_&MNw26*Cl15FD@MGpVGJ zO?yx&jq-}1=5;Y;)UsZ*k;VQS`dxsKOYx^t3Q-bNqmk1DQm#}Z6+;xYYCx@4$&Oj8 zLQPl%j0V`m?sN~Zn2WYE30sx&q%*(&=>q&y+yAdWy8shx&07aXD5Q1BVl_mzQWam7 zGHr~KaOEmYAykZH3PH}_Kp;(1RbSN83AUR_*kVvsBtof@n0I-cDO=mj<+=b3A%$a* z$5|?9E!;}RsaPdWMww!PQR6QwJ0DVr_x$%Y*2wE1+UO|+xDp2+(; z;bI_A$u+wGvnGyP88Sz>yabJ_5~7n*BwlQ#GUXbsbp(e()$l)1>OWJZ3-FI*{Y&Rc zQ!97EP^PH@&&{uy**H(-JHd$GNCk=_!thEm7NcBLLlv8eE> z;hvyRl5k8SD(Q+$SHmva3@JoNMvB!InGTf-ey-}^A{`Tkp z?J5fCX+|>`B`l}w)mF-E6f0eTs*=?`EF`r$z%%vLY1IM&fl9^K1}B0r;ZT}xWi2aR z4f~)(q>>^yG=};~%^>Rvhm|2aMvF9DHDfsg*1G_kIxKKPA|G_gvQHA=C>NwKURJ_T ziX~GLmo~*x%@Dn&kqyHQ2IVl7g`l=gHd%}$yd^~QkVZ~R=NnAD3lMU7VXf}opJ3Bt}UKsg?E z2RcAhHd#3s@szXPEM*Zyu@TO*YQx5(NG%?AnfXK+QJs)ljGDQ6k_{(-0&sU=XDgd6 zHXCxWlXga8U4TKsFUV?}P*ugNg!N<{R^4eNU!vW4jH?oEw925Y&mXNZp0eJ;Avo)! z?eTW7Ce!wC(30~w9X13hofXq$7a)6PQY;iHGNqFFRLYYNDNh>k{*|3DxUD^u}oPnA%ZNc2GQwliX2oGk;s#* z&`zbQZp%rfBuR8S?K&GLTbYdDWMRtW{r zWYyVY8-}h4{xH#?Z6Z&k5d>FtE{Ru7GaH2MY^7F6>N@3WXZ4U_5jI;}$WhU}Mug*B zu}H@eS0@8&Ny3Jf6B(+vDSVhSZG?c?TG2o`9;+}Q4O4BjD4JJmFh}@Ry+}4`I}#z& zE_Dp`-hwm~@|Kh;hyuH#=~AqL z)3n?LsM?h#kw>LizzH?{d3Uo$inymkCqnf^45OfCsMPjpHJ43s224jn@kTxr;X0 zD$=+`W|@4MHnCPJ9y9V{(cg?mQy`+_&D6PAwF@xS#TU-91y*XhYorEcAzd~qWZFPY zG3K-t6t}wy@C`b0L4a=>Eo9^vSuVGeDwl)2K41eDz_IBtGSUTzNAo_^O8bB*7gEb< z4_U&PcB`c6Oudqgw&D}??c2GU#N)oI#mZYPqtD4 zzH+Q$?+I80#QGpnCdx5M$l5SZfk^YgWD}RODB&>4nuOE9Od&)zCDz)mC{*EeIim@7 z1d$>#Lj@@ZF4t19l7-Sey{xGs3^mgoCGR#_w#x7%QotF19P9!MHCl+I&`}I*lY~KN z(a>`tj>6KIB$FDF_OPtSTSWmgU0vQgI84MnqFw z9h*X%kXg|ih|&;Hh2RpgbhWCq&`6TQOS;b4GLla>;>9iv>57yDBEXkGNDdLQ;c&Q8 z&eS`m$fGvi9g5c@JWkqZKBaIm&c{|@-bP7WJRd5XiYZw6mM4{~`_*zN9qLIN%cDY$ zlI{pQilI`{@T8hbyu*m`6pc288XFXGH$&K4g4NaOglV(^Ax# z>Eu0yOuOg!_+8#qP%BkoT9o&gP#UjbXoJW$TyY%uhR=shqQxAY5Xc@*6<)mfMQt z_M=1rjWZ6>6V79(;?J8|pWCDY7_a&{ERibN=_K3ZLj?0Ch@9qftF>H>Cv!r*P!OCx zF41%r2@bZqyfjT>3|tMH{%kNHml{DcRV2ZN)D;{YIrj* zcZxdWD%pJQSj}K_6-baQDF*u@B`Fz97=l5flrNC>Fg^!ahFWkX)}(xp+Q?=dhHfjG z7KN9)D{LSV8fsJ(($pCr!(o~w_|+(h`h87*T9E=+3N6>&DM!|uj-l}i;}EP$*zaPh zrq@R@vg~SmJU)q|8?wLWn&lZrPV+XdR;a`Tq1^Gibh|Eyl|s^4R^n8eO6E9sQjZ`w z-GKe7+75d%q*xDS+g7Vys3;kb0CVsmors7%=dtZ=#*KK^-3cJL2TE&|PB4+>61o{I zmzyB#AVLrI{JZ;pw7WNVOHj1Wr^m z1q}CC6c%fIDbh^itsI}Ka4azEDryAw>VCt`qOF)eRBsdRDxGl_m1@jW^{@dAYcO3j zx&VXOAZ<2%jFN3;F{sk6WjnmZhuu~z(sU9wsj9o`EjEY%izblGfD=>D+pv-(?B#H+ zjR4^tsv>qVCKQt?q6e_!ibQR$EF$S`Tc_#tCJ9gQHzTrL15f%`Kt#cc9QOyD1vpme zXl>kW_dyKYpmS)XiE^|Z;z(_aq8F@s4Gvl?lV)VH2@KN+>}M4x;4G404L~syg{8D& zVdWC=N};+`Dz}*`Q4nQ&u2OX&oS15sjU2B^JtY;*6EGWQIAEve%SK9TiE^gx^rEKX zMLGCF_lte9A_Lx?%5$QDA1lh1;mpv~djxq=Q7fX(?YCNTe&}Ifxi>Z>@ zQvr#rqU3p&1y&Yb?tnBaha{@GHp5kEHI|O@Y#5WpbOzH9ESRwrMPYmx4ta7FfvCV- zy2E55w6_xFs+CU9a&V|MGU1VhlGBo-CMWv^3CZwSxdG%OCRl<)iUN`g86gPCvgQFk zb>7Uh+Xae;Gyu9GCu$5DYP&F{(z9&}l*-kcMj>o*M45?W@lKj3$(Dx@>t?1>fNGtz z4=|Z48AY<-nIVJAC}KHm8g#Q1b!%YWyf4gYO4-q9_S9$zv8igYP?SUgEf>p)rr$?6 ztJP`%=rY}*7~u%(^;bkM5$wb*z#kg!%Hlx`R!A#FCY?N!Z%EN{rVN3oM2`>M5|NRE zVL_#0I%-cbS-mObIv(IcaTN}&rxlosTP*@&NyF1bVr~sC#lvbyLULM#ig0zy;6Vnx z4QHx73pP#AP|hcK!j?-+C(@Ltc)@&_kkYwEt4+l^E{)F+oKTKeq)MkGOAL;v;3Sf1 zfh_necd+A(^Yu zMU#szHyja@WvUYP>HrNB7^gLkh<0L10z^hQp&7U7Ua$ce!Suuzq)Gy55u6 zjwFjSaMqh>yHirkRu9pYhIhaV&X6!9H!2uij*@G{sb*RA&9HN~q>Y(kZUWhGZy_GYEUc zg6&~fN-0M}Mw)6v2G{iC1Q`R?es@z^7^^ygBb>??y$Y43m1HWLk@T{MDM_{nUQ{rb z>9rCq8!NJP#1{?Get%7u5f2HgsKo#3D-SrwU4XxdK9&QHkHG~wMI}&2jH_i6#d?L4 z1d`4-Yzcc^R#dKtEh^Gr6OaP@}yFYBg0j$7d8M_FnMo_lOOf_1jd>q{cSj~GN zxT*1C)*i}yB~v6C2(TW5TGe0>hs6Q8*i@|~lWH<))GH^lP{K;*TX=-GAYlF3 zT^UzI)oLa2cUcneh& z2-2cJ&hw?V5YlbD=|R;xs%l83T+zt70p;_pp7<&LBmyJRWHRW zrXv)q24Vqk8mWZsC8m*##hGwO3m4k93Son)?Hy5Pvdn5tw{+G zf3rx`W1zaTE@M>HW+XFuK`vz=Sm5zUCgO4qXr*QY3Flq$OgWNnu^O`RL6>t76G9txEs}$sC5Fd>#TF?$^GPKF`{X)pF_s?=G>L?i z1o4LiR8Juia3TX8JlQGal5opj3O8cClftzbx|55PiuP=&LxP=bh-EIAQQeYFHb4~0 zgalXvy2$Sj>YCDM)sbR?&NdUe?rT|YHt$Q>v2;6=moPltqaoQ$L?PAAHl;GiH4nO38P%4qQ{kM7;}z4g*?e4Ql-b(Q998y zAf`@bsf<@E+j1P$0>*e7&f;>ILaUOI@>aww2b3&OjKHdj-~~tB?yv!kqXI!P5UK;g z|A<#g_59@`DJ9}w;XvTqgzthKugVb&XYlsQ3skYGdg2Y2}{dCVk(t{ zeIO)MKq4G(t3n||F6&Ga?xJjWcHm&c)oB{GM$P2?wLDUQ>ajfUHh@Frg6*Lga5~Wt z?yVqtyJRuEqgHqK<}QK%n<>0ZJpRW!lLA4>EEG$ctcR_#YEe$A8Hdh<9C|6=CTqbi z%8b#ZD_JR=!y+ohu@Si=iBz1?3AgHXWk4ttm22@daI3-%1xmre8k9Ceu}FYv+RART z32cITxM8z3h@{wa9)r$m4d|2sO9TM%a4G-imiaHJ0Q?ErNI}D0%a%!Z2 zI*1Gb_)+1=3NMI^o`+hgHtNM1Di@8$`3?&gW3tQ7cX*}a3xa4{Bh_=wK+=T83q@84 zgG@3A&Pr}rW2#6UYhn?l05^g$oXM1$shCi5F&#aG0M$uVd`wFsLAJo|4W#0=KvK5L znBFsq=~CEjf*52tCl(`i0>Rv2dlAN|Kuni`0px`$WgnwuS^_Y}EXFY70g#PjX#ocy zX*`LGSjB~V&``zg?x74ce$C-dNK`l~G%TMzl`i_CN(gnQ(h9D{X&MmL16<>vSfT;3 z!?X>~`DBkLLKh*M%!RYn2x1TGS*nIb+IgqWhn;I zXc4BJkF$zD=o9O4*zRWPsN3-Jbs9HAsX!#+D}#Uo7neIdqaF5R@kFwOW-WJ_Pq`8j zUI&4z44VrPUQ(A`RXN+N=YzTwMB_vr1fWIOw1@IGIzl(<4GPZ_QiH^+sv;$OGz?Zy zGNTmhHE*N>LiKjt54cNrm~`B$X5;=yB;sN0v|`k~@uX1nQi>0VTSE?^uq@&r?AVcN z{*(=66aHk+SSprTELjzOB^2sZVT`a4Bi6C#4y0u2sbDN4dJ&(CX7Q#T><~JvH0fqD zScuULJ;O?6+$4O_T0B<#6Sic93ZiOj&LC{8SNl(Ya2` zWeJeztwUlBm4nR+6iE7Nzz7Yu0!BCxVK|0qBe*}pbOA=pFx|=l>!89p%6UeY+Br!n z+c3jd&qoSyN^Um*zt!T1FM}!0rX(pWn@ii-cFg05gCa}ZZ=}PfH!Lx>o?iBIC4Y^~ zhFuLwgf)R68sVUsfrF41$xv0M%*1Flfe1clOy|YClW^21z$`LWth(GeJE4$qEJuaB zDc*`h-4&{SjMboafh7hEA*o3isHdhlqh3(hAGl?E6*CTJFJmW z3N~wILQJtP7NV675VSp%<9IwJhhQb$sbvhHxI$#urPZ`j;c_aLEY`ghgO1<= zkI->dMN_p%I+Nuk8|9}wWkXKH+k%TOQcbk3!#=807Nv5SsG+Vdz;ev5mg-X8Ud{0k zt@X>5qMbVu^gNZQ8;~PN8zbOgD`noTwEk zl~lNPCnDh)yQ}A?fXI*+6UCh6!{UNuYl)IK;42QC&J5Ry(q*iJMQJ3BWGW4RN(e`i zpbSAb0;V4X%gs>B#}+tEMJW!k)p{p|Ye`YYh#-bHUEm29+2nweXu(icQbdQxpCMCZ z8mm`4Vn9kH90pp+Y7WTki!7<5G;)C*#`4M<}dgTYC>06aJ#V-(3s zqri4*=PeU>+;TMz>GpgfqKc73*@sD491FTw*3B0JCAP^D0SP2ano+)%?9#BMK^m#+ zVyKceviSta=Q(7GXR1QObQEkLu0m*(R^&u3tpyd@C-W{ipO=*ml#Q4%6zB87xKa&+ zu$@!sIX-^F6V(X2YCz=>CdERMU?3737jjL64>faMFKI%+AyC^@vktP69TzOSg=7Gt zVl>xsSZ)mi;w6~Jy)G=^io=npw-L`NNHeYn`FNdG1p|jN1}Lf~ zqq(-9F*+Pl(()Nj$hx^&MUbd0ll26fbW65+&LgTu+prNK1r^5Qq6-1KyJAmhp;XG~ zSfpl)plwDG2?L|v{Jh+l`8x{GO7937cpgSebSSQF;U5J&mtYNDpmHEzoa zO%KB}tP&2l$zVHXniL-)S}afSu(MOdaKleIGmy^*(Oi`404Ep9uxQFg*F_s*HCeZi z&5|9j8xf*qrDtQ~oUP>aRs&2x&_v+wl|ueVfzd(G*c%e)WR48y%0x4r!^$0yR|PRo zjf2uq9h7@TMZ$198d|x?I4QG&S9)5n7z~g>2xY28J5CB!MmCHX=V9}tg-KMhZPPVR zg>yACTpZ^@;UH4BfPf=NRRtCzW@6C<5sg|p!RF)bp0Sk83N=02X>*1f_#{kNL%o#_ zU(MBXIwX`jss#sGx&w!hPK?BJu~sx$BS8)pDHmkI9Sw$D6kAr~Y)q(Yy~vUb%1r#2 zrJJEZ+wO)DJ`GBBt7#2HRckdKGZ`Pk#j<#UP(i@HQG*Ip)nbK=-mnWk)Dtk99fr(= zASJ}bdofryl;!G_DMmzEP33$p!`Y@Slv5B|jl#giOL*F@yeruRyXZHv;l#arnS176>LONBTOm9r0ABE|tcU4On7LDbdp@ zJ`j27G_zhVuE)@p&ETXMA_@@WL>*D7g;`=I%(33E2Fe96AW3=fA_&r+Q^8Xb!2I_> zxipa%i7I9QTK4#m<{K~`Xs45P1D5Q1oJSlG;&jCdpb~`yp|6S*h)`$~q&gh6Og-T$ zb=V?aXZ2Q)hl4OtO?6_ah?-KX*p`e>Evb~#XiW^OM$8C;7fm@qGPlrb3vJUKW3dQ? zdaH=Lszg!|o^4cQ;O&AieI;Hs(MYgn1@k3mxD3i2^c2&}falAw67yDr3>ys9JXqeR z5(-e9j8V_=Et?M~G!P8b7z+f(G(wOvK$K%-I-UT)2LsS}ZIfaGXVg)um zUMNT@5vRA8hU;{&YLTeZa5hqDQ*=}bLgj|6K`1$pP4UO0j9&;gQ>?d|t|9@D*h!Hr zoQP0B{&g^>jzwH`D3m9%8pWzzc^CnaZ7v85Uk>2`;T6cT$zcK}AUNo*meu02KEa!ag;KV#*96m;0YuNW@^Qmo;(L7PDKuaZun}AFHeZfJ%MqWBn;jA> zFaeP7P%Tby#j-IRjo|e_MNSeaK>w&W95;O#RF8>-*BgxRtwO9ugnJ=VImu{k#a1bo zLk&9Vg9YGg`+-zWnM#nAr3?YWyogT-dILrQ;$a`6)U(OBuM;4EEy>sDsEr8} z5|$hFmcdTi_)Olyvb_}&#ZIQ>@3@5m*iSl}2y#4U6&h43&@PlvF@ls6e7hBk#Zq)8 znstb=us7gTF}_?z9UfN+V5-IwjK)`lO3$r;e2nPeu#_6nfWZmQ64iziO`;}QgtrD6 zK0)9bAoK{^f2`)>IgcaaXgV)MaXDf$PR;cinKUl5fW>VphC@5*7;Hn@P8j+Fsa754KeMJSp!MOm)vW5MS$s?^q&{W!LwJ9W8_5V^Gwx!UlyUV|n z)clXdXMYR13-B+sXnzkG#-fua|5gy(tM>hKJ@Egf^n9Q^e5*y&0|n@z&;*|b-m0hN zB%iCl(J197FcKmY*&KLqh7_f7Ihzd~N23xxjushE7cJsh@XTFzeSaML+Y-0Hb?Ldr zz%wlXE|_S19)Je#q7x~Kq{fNh)r;e76e*5la!7U@1wvY&tPU8mwqC6}0R6k+e*qn- zmB6D#qVl^w-K7&Q451m!#^B(5IKT`3P@A157{rC61VTIMUzWX<@qd|v2kF$(z|#gm zIn?X@Morg2J^8?c2R*X=>Hc5FyQEsFDdjyiUF|*-^xsR-Cv~5inNa%keu!D{?#C=T zj={k$60{>#|k7BujjL+^I}uUjI5q$iWl6XOV(7RTA- zyba8g&yCB=wk-Hh#&RgAh5yU&twGoSKkrHp{8q+qZJOGD+?XDiKi&Tg#4kJdyPf&n zBL!Qymi>S2UE6NsHV}R9R|tLC~&1dG&@}tjyr%wJ6#h` z3c6#sQx)!7Vz2LGy>Npx6~*jm+C-xa6stSnsVIpkMpZ8)4!>Emh zXG5r?*d}KZIYEpq!VRXIT2Td}va~w}7i(+TAkv01<;eL)v<$(wS?IzBf}})iZEJv) z)y%$TAlZqxi4MrAlGcT749<+MZW=855c8rKK2yR~;4SSD)Q_A;fb_;(ENd5%vq|N~ zo|DHdGbV`NJLko%$`&gwmn62P*<$wf#tC)>3VQ^lAp>|P-5;*+hwGhWS3VM@tErOK z;(#+1R8Ep>;BoCNr;FPtT)no`LAzZHu5fG3sT)$a%{p|InX3dVI!(q3RE>|kZkk1a-`NhceRUhk2lVX=Wpzfk>~izXu@hI z6wx@Wltc_%Sg9+L`_( z8=Jm$3N=h}kJYi};68X0t(M;0#p$xF?C(#{HC&36hng+$W@D9H zim$ZJL-;~>8D;qrL$h9L+-dtvYMA66-`WSI3A6CjxeEQ+UNNeAv`K4mGp|y9{uGe# zjV~r4Rf? z5g%9A!PNDOK-9%AA1;4g1231ru8Xk8JyBzU-CN+sf{+|fezOR1Q5|Xnt&jf%DEUEE zKb)deBfH%=sYhx2EMOWxpJoi{L&iyR9ddd;3TN9p;wQF>kWYpPJg1TYF}4@k1VyJc5JE5)a7!i b`Va+91)W?PwSTZ0sF=7Ye5z@^wDjqJUd2+S literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/figures/logo_univ_lille.pdf b/figures/logo_univ_lille.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..90cb94fe9bcdcc5264ce40c5711f563d85065615 GIT binary patch literal 5248 zcmb7Ic{o(<`zIokY_BB>W8aM#V=N&t2oaJs%a|EEGsY;gWJ{JpiL#4`Y>hn;k!;!b zLe?l-cC!6uw7k9F_xH#5`&@IKGv{;e=UzVNT+iozj(|Q~Ljo)*0}v=%EZhZ11Eqi% zTPJ{`A`o;5?Pia6078k7Api&jf;1dm@Ms+I?1I3f;b<0)gqMo z!K-n$Uo$IN_Kb2w2CZwYYY(I?YY&B{N081_tp$zUYa46Yv$JgelP9hXI-iRok$+70}2v{q87s-lgr<7GbkW|{N5_i+yd`Oi>L4|TnpXcaLYS@BGH z)d=3RRNmT^7^mH%_QA&*6e`&2QCx>cN4bU~Zi$cDma~?aq*k2Y&ZgPo`cNA!*A~L9 zkZkgzXolU#c`&EaZOY!l{dH9>yGXeqx4PUb>@0J;Pa#WTu}himzWxelzDSLJKrGIs zW@4yEqx2YZB?-cbi+I_PThh!PCax!)5c@SGSSJv1n{M>^V1YuSVf^e@DRj4F zIdQ7}Q_$>L&S6(RzH2O!=Q*y`#YDJ?o%EV$g-WM!NP!7ImYli(Lnfi>i#(4*>UAGG5M9gaw zMZ4%6<}h~>$O)Y+dJn0`3f9O?s9%?0@F#!m=iC8c5(U1?xnOU|cZ zc9h4bx~s2>h7^6?5?AC%#|g`FwNtX{N0`0_u8k)I&dsc0lRM0fCO(H+j66H6c5C;m zji{TRo;^5q)BdU=E9@-v!R-ox0KZ8lqoiYmCL;&1>Vleey2l42+qFKsQ0Y837>BsV zeM>!6@jyy{TgCXWK$$sKMdU-FTH8njdVWfYwlOy^Ben|@BOJs zdHD*}S^Dy0YCb!=ZTT#7*YdRY+R>stUby!08Z%XL7?v+PR2_tFDG|R|E>Pl9B5Nm9 zoSU06TKo=BuVQx9DdQ12kB!cIn4)&sI*Z(@)h4^XU}@h)-DU`>2EYvc zT4m?*EqUZ z2wv=baQ7jbPhbTC(k<~qg3YsNmohypW6|FJlG)RrSH6YKNXK+y+s}_>d zEz}~7V&!2)o;o*2B# zbY7*~J`T-hHx%k(uihshw!`0+)T?`@3WAr5pD%tXw%}?zv4Iu3DYf$+lSs?$l*AYzy-3H zsZc?tc|V^}Ult1=5-hJ~vN`v~Drn$5gK8>I24$bTpN*RMM^Ul;p)mdI2mLV;(%;2T z3t7KLF(+m4)i9<<2GdkAH`A~@ z=&3>PcHDCzr-fOhU<5nB9f6L;HZ95+Y%Kl%LO30{NbrmDLEyDewMY!qf(?FYz#m%t~4p~5xT zJy8tZ_6zl{e&I{ZciIv)1|Lvhx!8q=im67Es>u^{GySkp!9|I!j~jyL$c7r)PJHw# zOmf!4CD)I(+&4b$7I?v;q5nIlws21pADpkk&Qk-}Eg!3*d7dB0Dn#Jl<-)kXR83=j zM1g&oJ$+;IQ52AFK=RwSQ$;-G)5?7oHq!PIkS$5j*3)#L1lywO^8r38D#ST7Xk6d* zLrriK3!=}USz0m7znp`Gki;P*IK!)PI*73hW^&KfOW`Rn#4 zogqe3QFhgKp*jT}GVtPl^EO#u!EiTOx@S$TW0y)3_06rb2xqu@#4_S|Op33Qvu8wd zaS5RuwhfMLO?yM$#58*OnM+7Ur~UDpqs+)_7pl>#YJE@Azo7E;Wg#Fc-aJM+nTkv* zDF4GD`Z{5%VE{X3AeiG*s+WORR`IAv3%*g3sDo8!u~q1Wu^{ zVowvg0?Z5KO$B$kPFFO`GKW0sZ5fz0pp=BSZs)&HSCI^N8H*@4{h|XXrP=f~tW{yp zS*RCG3&OIM<4^6dXQe>WV%#~l%LtE6Bn7kk8iF zmQBz1hlOSX&b}tPHq%Wvi>+4Iv|4;n-?MqlN4V9~vrx1SfSaE?k~_1xUYKQ6Y`gPJ zMq)vY^TK4BbYX$fW5|uySx=6wtxJqOvWgx^)9t!K&mk$s6X|5Jwri-UVPru$^(tFD z!i#w!Gs7qGWazcAi``wU>x1C}{tktFgyD!mgP7tv&cMVBZGudZOloPS99!q5ry#p# z$bnV}jJvITvOTKmbIx*NQ*oA;c-~XZMbm*z_;qnL%Yl*sf{WOgI3La8emjKu35DWw%5yT_03n$+AaRixOwsk@y@kcgZGC&zp|4zC`{QZmp`yB%aGV;cvfgpW^ zJ^Cn~J_3h!!xLTpYWj82C`W`U#tUdcgrtCSQc^$&3??Zj3xl8*eP%mw47 zyQ}tEO^*k`ZJn5==itpI_iC4--FztDp2)7zJg3k78D@;#lFZO8+VfO0u2J@1U#{rcN^oLcrQS9F$iQ@G zT2r5D==BqSWz*VL?oOC$sU_=%#G6_Pr%wvW4$Iy1pT!v)wx!<{^vd(QY>}1gWvcqz zcgp`@w>f1$z2gGoxHWn{9yR1=zfLjz zT%%+g)_i*D;+i%%Z67+^}{AT5CIDCnGu5< zx%;SBiukCv)9hjwN){L^Zi)`1kZldJq+QKuG(P`DUW6w(z}=BLYSaO$ zO2?>?R5sE4RsQy&YsNkQ?t~RLU9WOO8%OAh>UCsl3wJ6oRJt=I!uWEU zjDSI~VQTfnTyFFDOPj(*U=6{>OyH8|bkq0BOP$@k1i}4_1@o=svO`03E$SeF{h>tu z*u+m<)Xi_s6)*(LULrfGjBJ@uiEnhC>V-%+&7M34Q=hB89#A$O;GQ{?zZx{dW?Fi0wp#Uetyw@oW>U!?XNxz9|eF>SJ+h^~yVH>O5Mz)mj;MDq^iJ z$EW#%2}(0Me2-q=I6(vSrg)mD_+%BBZ7g;2<8BHS%W`~5O6g&V5vX)&aMn7u_cPPK z1&FjN{uCfE7$)^g97qe;kM;9t)%za>=x>oBNyx8t_-~Q%IC84vi1Hu`3Q30ye`|;* zNq7EO$mRcVpho<}gva23!bpT84g&;Bf~6(FKw$?w9;*N%Y9JA`$04u|jz|wl49;Fe znOqP8i4-;gBl3X literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/figures/partner.pdf b/figures/partner.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c2406fd2ee4c54ad908d8890a41508dfdeeeace5 GIT binary patch literal 12685 zcmbW7by!qg_xDvox?5uCR2XtVy1Tmv7`hp{M7mQtM5MdByCo!~OF&vu@&)gB?kE2E zUGL${nX|up?O1E?wJ$FCP%DaxzXrbHK%%ZaD7!&o1F!(>j4Y9Oc>&C_5L+{-Ie`69 zQbqy*0L!3K4}E+nGR+`1z5XppFo*4U$`WshXS}HV~urMq>n%;Q+c% z=u1NXf{H5U-C_~xP+jh8RJG@!?c>$1T&Plv44q}4=9o{nF8ku&ZcBlvcnOgW;x~m? z+P|z7en}#GBeg{^5IkfmZI$X*#Kf({)b)awzF(U@)$s+dokUoimN$TlGLa2mF8roS zuPgdeGEA4s=EW5ecY>^~ROPdcydXF&=}gM~bi>cXcOrVkpfz1ls|MOmE+SZPY0@Ds zFI+BI%S#~Zmh*cTFvxOAp}GQBx-V#D21hZyZ_ZD9CrDTjM-QbU8q_eYkMoJ$#L*!Q z$ySoX{zC->y6eJLn_AFHwxakfDUoS{+0gE!(WRfZKxJoyur;SyonyK4(q9-Si&}zc zcFf8sJf)^eeMKIFF-a4DHHd#Am|JDrLVj0ExnT7KpJ(sel3Zor1sh5yMYso%eGvhx zBg%8{I4}4BCaKu1qXXd&op0z@xn z(`;?Ob9Z*&$h>c9x|N-}{5`@Vg=)Sp7el9 zt1I6lSzz@WVZTf)Eah6qxsXd=s?bZn)74AQKLtb9yKg|)pAZqVtCvi#IxWo_D}We}vVgqcLbt=BMDWhOxKWm%~eWZw7LH z##^J!y;^)!#M9M+8Cru~0jy8j7?dMn{VsM~8!*Eb)R_-yFEogFm@9Y%w$?}n_#$E7 zMzLIIfQ>@5>vRY`G$So9!(S4;a$K`}FBc=pgdWoF@ZAf3%MZsz_F^p47fRs}ZD;^y zV*$V{A_M>en2o`Y&&P~$9{l+wPTipm{@>??c4x5j}i-jlZE>Y2P+FV8wUW$&Gv=`$i>3N z0nq#1R^)L8kByxGPe;Qa=YWKxowNNvX7$Htztz9oQhA(%BiPo-{%K@m_rGK*0Mya> z_ne-57kRW2g}7K4LzE?ipG^LAS{dSG=j><rz^O61xu#~cZK*rS_B80i&FnPOmC;GXC(}DVfxhe7 znB(%GcLB+uN<25xx5j7EYjhFO%ei&6)-Y`L=q(Z(eU>E0glUn9Pp;(@V{^*s3jhVE@i09U5^a|CYTCnKx4G-+FTGUK{r*gA3h8O8OBAPYq!J=oF;POj(mTZiv5Ca1a-O8JD7&T;oJ zL9sW{y1}CeiVc*r$;?AT znlUo`>xZ!qhrP?MBCS1it&kkV-*E8T~6X>)ap~ z|II7EhSFzDoVvv6)(#b#Oq%d>c!nFw#>V0PVrrGpYKTxjwZCF0?5h+N&c0V7QN8fx z@s>IzC$bxXQJSgo1ATSk=4tHhLR@2UriA#?$dMEl5in_Sxlx3A+ArqcXrXP3B!-_j zsuFHkpKsK+pGmCWFB=?!IPI(Qo%RyPywmDkCYe|_56@x9F4|9$j^cTZyzgpfA5L>; z^|yYu<2tj4@uI|Qcyy#*$4&Kp$q!bfzlAO_&#a`{gv0ruB8kL_z<@z)1ae zQ=9;MeZettqyePZZf^dsP%2>;Q5OmGo{hmuF&9vXh^iV-{~AQr0h)hblxD-(qZ{FZ zMngj?F7Og^=43y_ZPG_b{C1eze_-~OH_CRhK&K^^WB{=({o&Tpr;WJoA@A*+qfhMX zZLZ3#3Rgj{YPegxI+nWelfXM`KCUm5_5sAtt6*GUASJ0$b^d(u!|L!Ksg?5< z+2Gf8@weIHWLzr)JA1e@6Q3IheNMBU!%x*citNqvcF*jNv?*rHyU0>x{=x13JeuP| zq1dAEUS+|uproLnprj~LvCAb`KdsI$S7?C1e_uvn4pvyFbe0^xZenf~=`XjqXzBzR9uytwj<*(g1+ z>1!sY`lvC|4KfWkF>p?8rG2Bb7I-SeWiJu@b_sox*J6~E$6Pa*CGm#fBH*Yn`^I}5 zop19k@7d`7WiV0E5>+(jROi4Bv`V?E!co=rM+1K_SV-Z^D@Fz;M*QLMGK_qjQH~zt zS)#<=8J#+9ALCzr*K#Akyb*EH+J=uKDp-#0_$WFY5opLb3k)_3HqF-bX*I)jvo1q4 zb4;@Dt<9O6lD)po_030QaUySIMGk))#lzrTIxD`g2(##WT zRL-l4Y%R0~Z^yRo^Rgxxr@X~U2`?_G8r_OD{>rw!g>xq@YhxXr(I_g)cx{~J)m1Vb zs<}0Ik4^WX*Z*{(!cTyvXav{6JtCVry!Yelt`aq<>io`x@fBZ@HA1{NWB@kI@yA6& zb+w+Y0*GNC43!Uu%@QP4pt)G>b>uf_l^4-;xPzsvU2U@w*(h~%E@8WJq1tMBwn>KI zhDWN+(QdL;l^ZSYWS60GbN1aLEw9mfCjEWL?)6$y|3Zt6>-6sEN~3l6t{s;Fe`1RO z`$x14ZQk77AG=8_EaotQ0@%)pJNKJjSg_&E%(wL1}ssTBbB8XyRUM`0!5rS)Fqb zQxukFf~kr-xo?swaZMtjE`BHMgY%4gu^Ofn}X3p4!dt_Z-mSbH?IB z_f`Sy=;=Iu>?o<$)pxqA626O~Vpcucrlob#Il4J7G$!WrQp&XasG*h9M!K7pNM~>> zam!;KE00j5y?H<2&_JWfS!Me}cm{-2 zBYXNVKZf^)EMW;mxc+qJRZPINVM#iNs>;j6^a%L5d+Bj7P7DzT+r-HEcN(W+ZgAoV ze2#cSf{p_lYIHV)eGA1PlydPi+Z~HjDdBWdIf(Y1Ls!p-+zEF6vG+|vSggH*wX3jY zg4(QV1*@EuEndZLTGo4`!8|5B7A_*_2!$K%6`&y$B0PfmUWq6{E5h!N<-;Fm6F2rQ z56WM2?ND3PeAXSj{7{_$ZbzSpV;}P9CjL6Q=GgmPc);j@`O=I$HBH4N7K`P`D6uQx=0sHM{sPTE><$~OLUv;g~`hqBr27{!x5OVHKCyejTbCn`H z1CX|3)f%NBlR7qLM=6o9OZ>jLSVi%#7=@CtkigG4B9WDOQWk1hLug{K5#_Fo zQn?D;p9YZP?fYH?HcF7TP_i`+t4vlJz^_$h)LHKi=y9DA=#Rl3?=Fh$<_>qth`Z`~ zVj3qyecgrm2IrjChmqc_-O;V=R7%TyT`}y5v}IVALT;esEt&?xA1KYOIpzeYaBL5S z1u}-&HruQ?jYE2azVlVdWPJHarw64~Qb$>IHhVzN$J=6gRfCGC=J#{Nah&VSDk3LE zUY_fa<&cvm(!0;NZ%Q04Lddun2wwcK%VR4`C?`ZYseoB%m=LIgFc8O-YC=un*C4a_ znx>ckq=D`-G+zwq6Afu+A{}cOOHt^yT+6`kd&h`^F>m8l6pH;1fTR4jUlC}ux{|504wIFtMcq4!s?y?OncLyD?iJJU3Apf+`>rQU7!rceOQ*Qbw~2WNWeM ze(2YIB{f?yIvJkJ^1O?l)`8ksuxzay@)57=>&Y5Y?|G>RDaU~pw4stfebWVVS{Js7 zY*KBdHc{H^S9XHz*gADat3^gque{5sc59L(Ozm3ESrr(*ibPVQh({go#Yf^{p~w!U zZl-+T7@kV_y6OIoAFyA;U&fzl4Ak__+k&Q4=xUo;)Y6nFXlAknwxRd1eSpHJ6wV&W!rEOK+LI$kYH|quZFG zn#$irGR-SkyWl7c?Q6nIZC8wt?m1kbi4OUwoV3M%USr8A z>A;#aQ!FzobxxM(tN8$C3&WdW_y$`&NS9rwV*{_H#1!(%B>epvk&~>;o7+?)p~7t*nosc=-H~k$5VROs0XQ8a1x>oj)7p5p!F6B8Y*;(}hCe6eA`0=;8gM;9$uf z+r9!1nJmW@Q$lyBRttxw5U$HTSbH$+CC+d;(8XpjlC zR_%(RT1+n09_D)xef|7W6c6$9FXRi^B09OyNY4B>7MW^EBOt&+_D9KDUvE zYowRh4tud8#w%mt2@9)BhM>jbM!bKB=WKa^KEOn`$lUw*+W34_{lTXrgNC9y<-XaL z`RcHV@?iMlqrI)E!^_3oeiQm}!?`jHvFAb~BGT`K+!b?DQznV4Ln^!4@hLP}XG{%Q zL_yxO zc#F?((46a~)zr>j$|9Xj<|hX^Y8Ts>HML@}&&%mz?KJr?2*Xto+no`W`te{w*l8D6a0SKaEh}B$j~xW>%>Cdn9t z9^oJ~FP7uTqJslH>BA*fi(Tw=U!53Vre(EQU&OoT6k7XmlXQjRaSZ;0091G-BN%KL zrqh^yNG1EG^yLTc$RKem|JDg_xiQCXq&?-E^TR!->-R_6Q65p({6p8p+vRQ1?uYAB zpN%{#tpZdnW^)-2&L?XpCl-Cf%+$hDZLlF>++igcvP#ybcAc1PN~1h|J&4uG^3o%> z;UOus4_#wbQL zZdZ~ZkBqR9JL$edykUjn7Uq=$t2%a>G!@Cpz;2;!9mk0y`r0~aR}$ARqbPKE7L~6) z``pR_yD$c~KRcXj ztjEx21Wu=%_p)L=ZXO!FuP-!aQPPRrw#gk=I=Nk2PQJw^t*pAhZ3wJcZI-8S?)h+M zxDPsQxr=w&-UUO&@gndpezN9Jdm2mujEF_uW^$@tZX<9d7pTls2}9sby7;#-@NBaV zyS~w%L}46#vFj$)!l70oHBM)e#&mBe?1cJPj6qeeG}SX>q%@-#Fhv@9XEZG`Y$L-R z8ihh%+2PqG9CEcWwbQpzX2l3-w8gapP2S4UNMVRF42MmacLYrshS0HkU}<6WhL|`? z#SI1s6`2dZrI)TUVo4q~6h;TnPM|s@CE6L5#`Jk}Jyd+&+!u7_l6WVsNb|13t|YQ{vFlfEoiR}p1yN3o0eue z1Z>T?eM13kSZqieR_jFe`XQU2#CJQ3=Ig<8gDhwaZ)I%YL9%l%nM_CUAwHjhg`jZlo5z%&LfiWuY_ zSt!{AaLRkqBxFffwwHI>vc|KoU5%!kFcC8g2;8?Dz+SpV?^B`21)nTuG#d2X%x=y; zY{x$wLe`oqhObw|6MXmFG4~DO2@4I^Z7AO(?H>hU4SipQT=@#@JdERi;~^7{I%7Ky zRXR3`xS;PcDSyVOVf&t} zQ+;!UcfXOubp18>Av%QlD_rj}g5wUR8_c#oT)iN35X18HHr-%a;L4gxniA2^Y$WVB zHGBL<)>^dh-M|xd0vL_1^Doj^g+bFxg`UdM-3r+fR~+I8rUQOrZtbzxX=lOHo-D*! z4fuz_#+#%YPRZYN;Ske*VUz@A2+sS9|v@)y7`|?5R@&y$iiZ7lu8aL z=1r8&Lt86(#@?kohuCU@lOiiJc{@El{c5$3k8`!?QiOKDzxkC9qC}_|Plg9^jxHHa zC+-!$-m%UkEy|f4QGrQ-I0LG`Be53T!}IbE%;_703AH#ehFIusb76f493>bn^TOWG^?DcX=pNc$ zt`DYOdsc?ji*O3v8a+~dafF+eRSAotb#Y`dH-oP>5q?FePt2e3ct~q9)F8Iw(5~~z z=u$2-*u);j2)r^U0I?ru!5HL9E9)4-4|UV<-nAaHv}vIe2f3c`!;@i#8eW9giwm2e z{UTkik7*vrF+q2agRZ@i7?9X>`U&@o_E+L3X_b^~i;(XdBzeWVsAm#qLLLN1lxO8< zuR19=k%8a@Me?3NHMgSDF0_^`YIas7u6&png3Z-W$!2F*_;5F*6GW3RhQG#r)!WOX5QUr;K(xl)kd_$6 zf30(^ldug}p_weLq`XU76}c?iWbRiZM5@pqZ(*+;K~ZXu*Stf>qn|AOV}MChULsE; zUTa*)(;Fnt7Jo#<3Xc$Q#KU=mO@XCpSQ*$N2K#+)1!z+<;q_ z(AY+iS9SzU*RiyY4>Q?ovIeVUK4LLv0|e6V$Q9UZmp)v5TVy#57`HM&~#; zOVMG9XxfPuvy$0-^O-)>uYpnPQr$oKw5c2F2z>dvN4~}Py^F9YqIM9E53Y9Qif|Hd znoBp_PVJyV;&g2JoRDtRI2#RPzpHTO%j=a9;1p{j2zo1vdHoS;NOU0i6{+;9t=~}mhgl&2*f}|k6mgE$p@55+`hnmlNNTy~@{Y9T zOG;s_@Nfs~=WdtJ@1v%*gD!8Oh$7s%lvb4q)~sp)!ZzqP^mw zBBDpw4z4lOx9!NpJMuIazRN$#na8j6oYS`pXjTZTXU!V`A=?Py;e3|1Mb0<|=_`-mu;M^*C? z0~hOgc7Gir9tG08IZU6fIA2$4|DwO4mse@(d87Wi(Nny;H-}ukZ=(U8Uxu<)?x42e zJVUalNsH)EoU8v;oC%w4VI>#X?t@QzqCM)Kg?1Tr&iwG#8m7AN{62u=uYg}mpCdbBvVEx1y2l>@YpfYQ( z$aSx&t92s{zC4#)_B$jwM|t-n}Gpvd5kK4BSeIh6n<*QC4Mp(Q@H3MQu!HxrTmWgOAKL^)u|KNb;^lmuS9K7h|AFOM1d!X(6zYM6z|-M0UJQ^>>alLyBCRw52an zh#AxDz-6U(#;ANm@5Vgo_aGT1*_H6qm|lbOmaC_Cd_02hqr+PK>+zkjSG|Ke`Co)L zSu`n-?B~qU=G{P-``?%vv&^?^dNfG)1&i>6C+wfr>;4MgMc&7KV85D@TFD_pr#Cs5 zL1$|DvA=vz%|M_zX3_I&w*^}U($&G9{JCqs)vUc3?RyUXo8Sn&Nk;q92KXXKgh<6b z+KXbV$_Jqc8>9io3e-I&%#Zr1X+Q7;y->=zS!$B_666AQr;6ODpcDCUIZ=T$*a1riv)%Yl<(6Uk5hb%8o6rq@*o z`nWkhuRRiZAV3gf*eGBZ0U6`*zeK_@zj$Y=k-(H)LIG1=qWHWSmkI0hd>O9CmMcGT zsaxjLZO803N4+(Ar_QGdcbl%m&T1TXEhvX4my+aUXGOv$YuS|J3~L9qCpEV47O&!L zdEFQj14v)IB_|j=z^ft;6@=rS%0V9UhMS1fdkKdbA_(_>SA*p%ZH#it z(6xtf)PVp?l1<3;B-j&F&7j_(Zn#?5!AP1fLh5 zZH=`6R8t&?j|p+DaQBRelXl84a6$fs3@`aYYLJbzA{0YeNWjm#Twqg3KmW=I_m|h* zba%r&kc)BY+HUcALCW#2jkiF8Hv5@nNk~*PF_6i{qWP0*^s=h}rxs@G4QY=iX6u3c z$_Uw*)F}$#uNAIZ-TJDhE`l9!Uy8 zEO)Bx_?}Y}rZ@_rvoe{~t)?U@ed6w~d9f>3w82;hI*DD<#|X4@N`^{10j5TNjr8i|mPVd9gnf`FqA ziE2n9D*-v}?3Rcb^rU%*AWXz$7Q;^`^N7un0xo!2`ItXQ^uJq(?EALM0%{6%e$bdH zZ?Ae^IV5?Mw?K|hSV^g3cXUg`H7DmYN$Ab5`9aPH#hpT$gg%%q)Q}Hv=JNlqHRr|j{VJCqcIPzd{#J~roQ&Dq~wX>$R`!uFTAGgNe%4Bl5MM0nUxP! zh!S>(%yUKQm4&4h2i0!FhF94O;L|#dSO`(z=K(|o&r#l7F!unzXX~-LPFD>`$8In{ zsO6fW(kM783nqz*5__g{RL+BKVv6;OGMOp3hcq-1-##CU#zALc(b>^vy9B&{|M-uy7-pvoGGq?I9v8;YEz_8q_~ApHr)t*5diaz9q&CKAo! z=cU9Je~ye@v~kj8%bGL}6M0Lro!xVrG0yhU*z{D8Z8LZKKz2NQ^%PY8P7O3}9)OUA z4MEUs^kAL4T-;uss%yIe`*$?j4%bkMF+?UjtgZ zu`XDl{JyLBQ;y(t`}SV(ps)a=8qvxxm8uc9Y6r=}6rjbW*bT=~=-!gZP zIh3eij47CSfHl_r47dCHJ zpub*#p)%z890(9bcfSGaI!~f?px@Z}AFMA5T#kv;Eq8x{k1#BmdOo{Fgwqv(zbC5Z zU&pX)>#lLSBNqEU*d`KmImYzKCi_Zqj3WruMZqKGSm>GH2_8HA-kXXW9&~G>vgL=> zh&RIYO=#??35Srg@{I_^%~kL6_?14Jtgd^UtTc&&)7Ew7La~h>5`kbSK8}r+%NL?4 zMCf%^xh2Si^@k_Qrw`Fm+KIauHpZ;^l$EA4J-AL{5hIdJDG;MU7pV)%g=iBy`4VnS zt`SsV`@)yzxKo)SW-ZFmEoa*0|;$RyKYj*(MZ=L=R*&1y22rsh!Z6o{#_xPHVlO6Dy zjg=k1%EH0|0J5-+~C( zUJ_zqX8wp+K6dk4Qh`Ej)B&JB+CLQ}|0+B=@rWuySOHHo<3H)fC$96qWAI0J&PLGR zOsDE2Klv1&->NX!3G$l|{h#r$aCCx-n1dbva$XkvXBi0O{N4QDBMkVx27hdRG22JD z+rriiz^q|mD`e|r@t5$sorZ-8)ZFP$cJwJ@{{MeCIiIjqF4iZ|^N~aSy*vKd+g~;R z)c)5y2L~tM_vdjb|9WTTdI~TLfc1Cp9FH|D01zA7-}Qg>^JMp%b$w)3?bK{7p15|v z)8X*XwfXP;`9#+`{f>u>g~?Mio;*?ho0@fg0&f3-t^)rB13!|lkHq}rrUuX%gDo8G z0Khju_BS8^ojDY0&%^wP0Y8dnj$nIp3uC7@c8+HBe{5w%M>`W|<3|Gj|K99hcrfsv zX#XD>CIWuk>2_wnefaIopM>zg8o4<_OpzXwgB|HHNB+D3oE#jFps*?64-Lr5!u9Cd z(*>~oQ)6KPaXtp@KQtEL;|Bi^4aD{s=zr55Hz()g%KV$g!otn>n# qV`V$L$MydgGc9Fn`nb-2^UO|Aup{($bb+jFKoAl&wU~l9(*Fay`_OX$ literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/figures/partner.svg b/figures/partner.svg new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f9f0a1f --- /dev/null +++ b/figures/partner.svg @@ -0,0 +1,262 @@ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + image/svg+xml + + + + + + + + + + + Command + Notification + + + Action + + Feedback + + diff --git a/hdrmain.tex b/hdrmain.tex index 47d487e..64445c9 100644 --- a/hdrmain.tex +++ b/hdrmain.tex @@ -103,20 +103,20 @@ \input{tex/introduction} \cleardoublepage -\input{tex/relatedwork} - \cleardoublepage +%\input{tex/relatedwork} +% \cleardoublepage -\input{tex/physical} +\input{tex/perceptionaction} \cleardoublepage -\input{tex/gestural} +\input{tex/directmanipulation} \cleardoublepage -\input{tex/haptics} +\input{tex/controlautomation} \cleardoublepage -\input{tex/something} - \cleardoublepage +%\input{tex/something} +% \cleardoublepage \input{tex/conclusion} diff --git a/tex/conclusion.tex b/tex/conclusion.tex index 390061a..01a3b79 100644 --- a/tex/conclusion.tex +++ b/tex/conclusion.tex @@ -8,6 +8,8 @@ Something about this incompletude phenomenon: ideas on how to tackle the problem +\section{Future work} + \begin{idee} Interactive programs have limited number of features and capabilities. They are bounded by their inputs. diff --git a/tex/controlautomation.tex b/tex/controlautomation.tex new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7fec9ce --- /dev/null +++ b/tex/controlautomation.tex @@ -0,0 +1,17 @@ +%!TEX root = ../hdrmain.tex + +\chapter{Control with automation} + \epigraph{\lorem}{Auteur} + +\begin{Abstract} +\loremipsum +\end{Abstract} + +\begin{itemize} + \item Métamorphe \cite{bailly13} + \item Living Desktop \cite{bailly16} + \item Ctrl Mouse \cite{pietrzak14} + \item RayCursor \cite{baloup18,baloup19} +\end{itemize} + +Ongoing work: facial animation \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tex/directmanipulation.tex b/tex/directmanipulation.tex new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bd48b6c --- /dev/null +++ b/tex/directmanipulation.tex @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +%!TEX root = ../hdrmain.tex + +\chapter{Direct Manipulation} + \epigraph{\lorem}{Auteur} + +\begin{Abstract} +\loremipsum +\end{Abstract} + +\begin{itemize} + \item Fingercuts \cite{goguey14,goguey14a,goguey17} + \item FlexStylus \cite{fellion17} + \item Haptic Direct Manipulation \cite{pietrzak15,gupta16} + \item Summon \& Select \cite{gupta17} +\end{itemize} diff --git a/tex/gestural.tex b/tex/gestural.tex deleted file mode 100644 index 1caa9b2..0000000 --- a/tex/gestural.tex +++ /dev/null @@ -1,17 +0,0 @@ -%!TEX root = ../hdrmain.tex - -\chapter{Gestural interaction} - \epigraph{\lorem}{Auteur} - -\begin{Abstract} -\loremipsum -\end{Abstract} - -\section{Finger identification} -\cite{goguey14,goguey14a,goguey17} - -\section{Summon\&Select} -\cite{gupta17} - -\section{RayCursor} -\cite{baloup18,baloup19} diff --git a/tex/haptics.tex b/tex/haptics.tex deleted file mode 100644 index a89b562..0000000 --- a/tex/haptics.tex +++ /dev/null @@ -1,19 +0,0 @@ -%!TEX root = ../hdrmain.tex - -\chapter{Haptics} - \epigraph{\lorem}{Auteur} - -\begin{Abstract} -\loremipsum -\end{Abstract} - -\section{Activibe} -\cite{cauchard16} - -Previous: \cite{pietrzak05,pietrzak06,pietrzak09} - -\section{Direct Manipulation} -\cite{gupta16} - -\section{Happiness} -\cite{frisson17} diff --git a/tex/introduction.tex b/tex/introduction.tex index 0917b8b..66069e3 100644 --- a/tex/introduction.tex +++ b/tex/introduction.tex @@ -3,6 +3,7 @@ \chapter*{Introduction} \label{chap:intro} \addcontentsline{toc}{chapter}{\nameref{chap:intro}} +\addcontentsline{lof}{chapter}{\nameref{chap:intro}} When I was a teenager, I was fascinated by computers, much more than I am today. I started to program early, and at this time I thought it was possible to create a program for everything. I believed the only limit of computer capabilities was the programmer's ability to code it. My limit was… pointers at this time. I wanted to create a program that was able to have a relevant conversation with me. I learned later that many people were working on this for decades. I tried the ELIZA system~\cite{weizenbaum66}, and I was not satisfied with it. It was just repeating what I was saying, and used a small set of expressions to ask me to make the conversation. Most of the time it spotted the right word in my sentence, but sometimes not and what it was saying just did not make any sense. It clearly failed the famous Turing test~\cite{turing50}, I knew about many years later. I think I wanted the program to understand what I write, without having hard coded key sentences or all grammar rules. Nobody speaks like a grammar book. Naively, I wanted to write a better program. However I did not want to code associations between concepts, words, metaphors and so on. I knew this was a huge work, that would take me several lives to achieve, and that when I will be finished, half of it will be obsolete. In fact I had no idea how to start. @@ -15,7 +16,7 @@ Later, when I was a computer science student, I followed \defword{Artificial Int The first time a chess-playing computer won a game against a world champion was Deep Blue against Garry Kasparov in 1996\footnote{\url{https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_Blue_(chess_computer)}}. However Kasparov won the match 4-2. The computer won the next year $3\frac{1}{2}$ - $2\frac{1}{2}$. -It is however only recently that computers clearly beat world-class chess or go players, with AlphaZero~\cite{silver18}, thanks to the recent advances in Deep learning [], which resurrected neural networks techniques. +It is however only recently that computers clearly beat world-class chess or go players, with AlphaZero~\cite{silver18}, thanks to the recent advances in Deep learning~\cite{lecun15}, which resurrected neural networks techniques. \myquote{Machines will be capable, within twenty years, of doing any work a man can do.}{Herbert Simon, 1965} @@ -24,15 +25,14 @@ This is still far from being true today. Machines still have to be programmed fo \myquote{Within a generation, the problem of creating ‘artificial intelligence’ will substantially be solved.}{Marvin Minsky, 1967} The definition of “intelligence” or “artificial intelligence” is far from being consensual. -I would argue that computers are still far from being intelligent as we would measure intelligence of a human being. -Dessalles argues that despite their capabilities, computers do not even know they are intelligent~\cite{dessalles19}. +Despite the tremendous progress of Machine learning in the past years, I would argue that computers are still far from being intelligent as we would measure intelligence of a human being. +Dessalles says that despite their capabilities, computers do not even know they are intelligent~\cite{dessalles19}. +Neural networks are still tied to a particular task, and are unable to evolve to different problems. +They still require humans to design them and train them. -\myquote{In from 3 to 8 years, we will have a machine with the general intelligence of an average human being.}{Marvin Minsky, 1970} +%\myquote{In from 3 to 8 years, we will have a machine with the general intelligence of an average human being.}{Marvin Minsky, 1970} -Not only it did not happen in the worst case scenario predicted by Minsky. But it is still not the case today.\\ - -At some point I realized that this idea of a computer able to have a conversation is futile in the sense that this is something humans do very well. The point of playing chess or any other game is to have fun, or challenging other individuals. There is no point playing chess against a computer (or anything else) you cannot beat. -+ about machine learning +%Not only it did not happen in the worst case scenario predicted by Minsky. But it is still not the case today.\\ %http://biology.kenyon.edu/slonc/bio3/AI/TIMELINE/timeline.html %1943: McCulloch and Pitt propose neural-network architectures for intelligence. @@ -48,7 +48,7 @@ I learned $\lambda$-calculus~\cite{church32} and Turing machines~\cite{turing38} These concepts define the notions of computation, calculability and programming language. In the late 30', Turing defined a \defword{computable function} as follows: -\begin{definition} +\begin{definition}{Computable function} We shall use the expression \defword{computable function} to mean a function calculable by a machine, and let “effectively calculable” refer to the intuitive idea without particular identification with any one of these definitions. \end{definition} @@ -126,6 +126,8 @@ Instead of finite set of inputs, interaction machines are connected to single (S Their expressiveness in not defined by induction, but respectively by non-well founded sets and co-induction. Induction (hence algorithms, TMs, $\lambda$-c, \dots) outputs are recursively enumerable while non-well founded sets and co-induction outputs are non-enumerable~\cite{gordon94}. This proves that interaction has a greater expressiveness than algorithms, allowing Wegner to extend the Church-Turing thesis for interaction machines. +The trade-off is that interaction machines are not made for finding optimal solutions to well specified problems, but satisfying solutions to evolving problems. +This is precisely the difference between rationalism and empiricism. %Now, Interaction as described by Wegner includes every paradigm that can handle infinite streams, including Object Oriented programming or Neural Networks for example. % is more powerful than algorithms\cite{wegner95,wegner97}. @@ -142,59 +144,171 @@ At the opposite, the interaction machine plays the whole game from start to fini By using this mechanism, interaction machines sort of include external behavior. It is obvious that Wegner's echo interaction machine passes the Turing Test, twice at the same time. Therefore, more than just observing the environment with sensors or probes, it can absorb any external computing or thinking power. -It is only limited by what it observes, and the encoding of this observation. +It is only limited by what it observes, and how this observation is encoded. %Wegner presents interaction as a way to extend algorithms with external computation of some sort, with his interactive machines. \subsection{Beaudouin-Lafon} + +Beaudouin-Lafon defined the Instrumented interaction paradigm~\cite{mbl00}, which extends Schneiderman's direct manipulation©\cite{schneiderman83}. Instruments are tools that enables users to interact with domain objects. To do so, the user performs actions on the instrument, which provide the user an immediate feedback, and perform a command on the domain object. As a consequence, the domain object returns a response to the user. The immediate feedback provides high level of control thanks to a fast perception/action cycle. The response to the command lets the user know the result of his actions, and allows him to continue or correct errors where necessary. + +Beyond instrumented interaction, Beaudouin-Lafon describes three interaction paradigms: \emph{computer-as-a-tool}, \emph{computer-as-a-partner} and \emph{computer-as-a-medium}~\cite{mbl04}. + + +Reification polymorphism reuse \cite{mbl00a} + \section{My stuff} +The idea of computers replacing humans for every task is futile. +The result is not always the only important thing, sometimes it is not even important at all. +The process, whether it is methodological, artistic, technical or athletic is often the reason why we perform these tasks. +We not only run for going somewhere, most of the time it is for keeping a healthy physical condition. +We do not play music or games in the quest of an eventual optimal performance, but for entertainment. + +Chess and Go playing computers are often cited as examples of the superiority of machines over humans. +In my opinion, Chess or Go are not convincing and fair example for this, because these games were designed to be challenging for humans, not for machines. +Rather, the point is about showing what is achievable thanks to computers. +Following Engelbart's vision, my objective is to use technology as a way to augment humans' intellect and capabilities. +My rationale is to study honestly the strengths and weaknesses of both humans and computers, and use the best of both to resolve problems. + +It is up to us (researchers, designers, developers, \dots) to decide what we delegate to machines that follow our instructions, and what we keep doing by ourselves with the help of interactive tools. +It is first of all a matter of purpose. +There is no point playing a game against a computer you cannot beat. This is not entertaining, and it is unlikely you can reuse its strategy for learning how to play better. However, Garry Kasparov proposed the concept of \defword{advanced chess}\footnote{\url{https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Chess}}, a variation of chess in which players can use computers to get an overview of possible moves and their implication. Kasparov's idea was to increase chess level, eliminate bad moves, and give the public more understanding on players and computers strategies. He claims that such an advanced chess player is better than humans or computers alone. + +%\myquote{An advanced chess player is stronger than a human or computer alone}{G. Kasparov} + +Delegating tasks to computers is not a matter of computing power and methods, but also a matter of trust in the process and the outcome. +Whatever the automatic system capabilities, we need to know its status in real time, to be able to influence its behavior, and to take the control if necessary. + + +Continuum between Beaudouin-Lafon's tool and partner. + +instrumented interaction for partners? + +\begin{figure}[htb] +\centering +\begin{subfigure}[b]{.45\textwidth} +\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{instrumentedinteraction} +\caption{Instrumented interaction} +\label{fig:instrumentedinteraction} +\end{subfigure} +\hfill +\begin{subfigure}[b]{.45\textwidth} +\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{partner} +\caption{Delegated interaction} +\label{fig:delegatedinteraction} +\end{subfigure} +\label{fig:directmanipulationextensions} +\caption{Extensions to direct manipulations, for tools and partners.} +\end{figure} + +Evolution in time on this scale (ex. with machine learning). + +\begin{definition}{Fluidity} +\defword{Fluidity} of interactive systems. +\end{definition} -\begin{idee} +Rigid systems perform long calculations with rare notifications, therefore rare occasions for the user to see the result, and change the partner's behavior. Fluid systems are direct manipulation/tools: calculations are fast (at least real time), the user has a continuous view on the system's state, and can interact at any time. -Algorithms are not designed for knowing how their inputs were built. -Humans take care of this information. -When reading a sentence, one may interpret it differently depending on who wrote it, where, and who was supposed to read it. -The context is a complex combination of background knowledge, alternative inputs, … -Interpretation of input must evolve as the context changes. -Algorithms must be modified. -Humans just deal with it. +\begin{figure}[htb] +\centering +\includegraphics[width=.5\textwidth]{delegationevolution} +\label{fig:delegation} +\caption{The evolution of delegation over time.} +\end{figure} -Algorithms are made to compute an exact (sometimes approached) solution to a well specified problem. Humans (hopefully) find a reasonable solution for non-formalized and evolving problems. +Discussion on initiative? co-adaptation \cite{mackay90} +\subsection{Technology incompleteness} + +Every time a new technology is out, people predict the end of older technology. +Voice recognition was said to replace keyboards. +Gesture recognition was supposed to replace the mouse. +Some even claimed that tablets will replace desktop computers. +In reality, even if these new technologies proved to be useful in some contexts, they were unable to replace them in all contexts. + +\myquote{Everything the best for something and the worst for something else}{W.A.S. Buxton} + + +\subsection{Designer as part of problem solving} + + designeering\cite{huot13} -\end{idee} - -Humans started building computers as an exercise of thought. -Computers quickly could perform operations organized in \defword{algorithms}, such as calculus on large numbers, that humans could never achieve with their own skills alone. -Nowadays, computers use advanced methods such as \defword{machine learning}, and clearly have capabilities beyond human competences. -Computers can beat the best chess or go players in the world, with highly trained neural networks~\cite{silver18}. -This example is often cited as a success of \defword{Artificial Intelligence} (AI). -This is undoubtedly due to the fact they are considered as difficult games, and requiring high mental skills. -In reality these games were designed to be challenging for humans, not to be challenging for machines. -Their rules are fully specified, and the exploration of possibilities is easy for a computer. -%Things get more complicated with variants such as Real-Time chess\footnote{http://rtchess.deapthoughts.com/}, in which players may move any piece at any time. -%To balance the game, there is a delay between moving a piece and the ability to move this piece again. +ever running systems ~\cite{black10} +adjacent possibles~\cite{kauffman95} -(examples). Go, Chess? Turn based games with fully specified rules are easy for computers. What about real time games with random events and multi-parameter environment changing in real time (SimCity example)? Tetris \url{https://arxiv.org/pdf/cs/0210020.pdf} -However human still have expertise in plenty of areas long way off computers grasp, to begin with the design, implementation, maintenance and evolution of software. -(other examples, creative activities). +%At some point I realized that this idea of a computer able to have a conversation is futile in the sense that this is something humans do very well. +%The point of playing chess or any other game is to have fun, or challenging other individuals. -The field of \defword{Human-Computer Interaction} (HCI) was built on Engelbart's vision of computers that extend human capabilities rather than replacing them~\cite{engelbart68}. -Advanced chess: human + computer better than computer or human alone according to G. Kasparov. -\myquote{An advanced chess player is stronger than a human or computer alone}{G. Kasparov} +% Algorithms are not designed for knowing how their inputs were built. +% Humans take care of this information. +% When reading a sentence, one may interpret it differently depending on who wrote it, where, and who was supposed to read it. +% The context is a complex combination of background knowledge, alternative inputs, … +% Interpretation of input must evolve as the context changes. +% Algorithms must be modified. +% Humans just deal with it. + +% Algorithms are made to compute an exact (sometimes approached) solution to a well specified problem. Humans (hopefully) find a reasonable solution for non-formalized and evolving problems. + +% Humans started building computers as an exercise of thought. +% Computers quickly could perform operations organized in \defword{algorithms}, such as calculus on large numbers, that humans could never achieve with their own skills alone. +% Nowadays, computers use advanced methods such as \defword{machine learning}, and clearly have capabilities beyond human competences. +% Computers can beat the best chess or go players in the world, with highly trained neural networks~\cite{silver18}. +% This example is often cited as a success of \defword{Artificial Intelligence} (AI). +% This is undoubtedly due to the fact they are considered as difficult games, and requiring high mental skills. +% In reality these games were designed to be challenging for humans, not to be challenging for machines. +% Their rules are fully specified, and the exploration of possibilities is easy for a computer. +%Things get more complicated with variants such as Real-Time chess\footnote{http://rtchess.deapthoughts.com/}, in which players may move any piece at any time. +%To balance the game, there is a delay between moving a piece and the ability to move this piece again. -As we may think\cite{bush45} -\begin{definition} +%\begin{idee} + +%(examples). Go, Chess? Turn based games with fully specified rules are easy for computers. What about real time games with random events and multi-parameter environment changing in real time (SimCity example)? Tetris \url{https://arxiv.org/pdf/cs/0210020.pdf} +%However human still have expertise in plenty of areas long way off computers grasp, to begin with the design, implementation, maintenance and evolution of software. +%(other examples, creative activities). + +% The field of \defword{Human-Computer Interaction} (HCI) was built on Engelbart's vision of computers that extend human capabilities rather than replacing them~\cite{engelbart68}. + +%\end{idee} + +\begin{definition}{Interactive system} An \defword{interactive system} is… \end{definition} -\cite{mbl00,mbl04,mbl00a} + +\section{Outline} + +Elements of perception/action + +\begin{itemize} + \item Lagmeter \cite{casiez17} + \item Friction textures \cite{potier12,potier16} + \item Activibe \cite{cauchard16} +\end{itemize} + +Direct manipulation + +\begin{itemize} + \item Fingercuts \cite{goguey14,goguey14a,goguey17} + \item FlexStylus \cite{fellion17} + \item Haptic Direct Manipulation \cite{pietrzak15,gupta16} + \item Summon \& Select \cite{gupta17} +\end{itemize} + +Control with automation + +\begin{itemize} + \item Métamorphe \cite{bailly13} + \item Living Desktop \cite{bailly16} + \item Ctrl Mouse \cite{pietrzak14} + \item RayCursor \cite{baloup18,baloup19} +\end{itemize} + diff --git a/tex/perceptionaction.tex b/tex/perceptionaction.tex new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c572ba7 --- /dev/null +++ b/tex/perceptionaction.tex @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +%!TEX root = ../hdrmain.tex + +\chapter{Elements of perception/action} + \epigraph{\lorem}{Auteur} + +\begin{Abstract} +\loremipsum +\end{Abstract} + +Previous work: \cite{pietrzak05,pietrzak06,pietrzak09} + +\begin{itemize} + \item Lagmeter \cite{casiez17} + \item Friction textures \cite{potier12,potier16} + \item Activibe \cite{cauchard16} +\end{itemize} + +Ongoing work: haptic latency, haptics and embodiment \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tex/physical.tex b/tex/physical.tex deleted file mode 100644 index 4b2a8cf..0000000 --- a/tex/physical.tex +++ /dev/null @@ -1,17 +0,0 @@ -%!TEX root = ../hdrmain.tex - -\chapter{Physical interaction} - \epigraph{\lorem}{Auteur} - -\begin{Abstract} -\loremipsum -\end{Abstract} - -\section{Métamorphe} -\cite{bailly13} - -\section{LivingDesktop} -\cite{bailly16} - -\section{Flexstylus} -\cite{fellion17} -- 2.30.2